Stephen Le Quesne

By Stephen Le Quesne

I HAVE been going back and forth for months now about whether to open the minefield topics that is farming in Jersey, and our food systems. I am very aware about how little we constructively discuss the issues surrounding growing food.

I am also mindful that this topic will more than likely lead to much more pushback than other topics I have written about and maybe some very defensive and rigid positions. In Jersey, farming is very much part of our heritage, our history, which is perhaps why we kind of just let them do their own thing?

We need to talk about farming, as there are many storms heading our way which are going to directly impact on how we produce food, its price and how much food we have available to us. These storms are climatic, ecological, political and economic, and they are ones we cannot get away from.

When we look at our global and local ecosystems we know they are declining, declining devastatingly fast, which will directly impact our lives sooner rather than later and in many ways. We also know why nature is getting hit so badly and so fast. We have climate breakdown, urbanisation, pollution, land drainage, invasive non-native species, habitat fragmentation, disturbance, disease – the list is many. However, the single most important factor is intensive agriculture. No matter how you look at it, it is an uncomfortable truth – especially if you are a farmer.

This intensive agriculture is at play with Jersey Royals (for many reasons), whether this be how they are grown and produced to how the fields and land are managed and kept clean for them. Gone are the days when hedgerows were managed by hand with sickles and small tractors were used on côtils by small independent farmers. Many of the smaller farmers have disappeared and the non-profitable côtils have since been abandoned, left to be smothered by bracken, brambles and scrub.

I am unsure where to start discussing this area, as it is so large, so what I will do is create an image, a story, of what I would like to see within a farming system that is flexible, durable, biodiverse and resilient.

I would love to see the government lead on the position of making, creating and supporting smaller farms, which are less industrialised, more connected to the land they use. Currently, the produce we grow is seen as a consumerist product, not something that connects us to the environment. Our soil needs to be protected, studied and looked after, not taken for granted. Every winter and early spring when the brown water flows off the fields, that is the health of the soil being eroded and washed away. Nature and farming need be seen as woven together, interconnected, and not seen as two different things. You cannot have a resilient, sustainable food system when nature is an afterthought. As a basic minimum, hedgerows should not be mechanically torn to pieces by big machines: fields need buffer zones at the edge for nature. Corridors and places of refuge are needed for the insects and wildlife that pollinate and keep the soil healthy. The toxic cycle of chemicals, pesticides and nitrates must be phased out and stopped; the use of these products and the imbalance of our soils is a huge vulnerability.

I want to see detailed agricultural programmes in our primary and secondary schools, as well as within adult education, so that we learn about the true value of food, with topics such as regenerative agriculture, rewilding and food security. Currently, grown produce is not valued for the hours and dedication it takes to grow it, and we have become too comfortable with consuming food that is out of season.

All these ideas have been put out there because of the challenges we are going to face in the future and the fact that we do not currently have the tools in place to deal with them.

Climate breakdown especially is going to change our food system forever. It will change what food is available and when and will force the price of food to increase steadily. More extreme weather events mean more crop failures, leading to less produce available and possible food shortages. Jersey needs to be in a position where we rely much more on what we grow, and make it worthwhile for everyone: consumers, farmers and nature. Now, we are going in the opposite direction.

It makes me nervous writing about this for many different reasons. I am not against farmers, I am not against farming, but we need to discuss and admit that our current farming methods and agricultural policies are not sustainable and leave us in an incredibly vulnerable position for what lies ahead.

  • Stephen Le Quesne is a naturalist, conservationist, forest school leader and nature connection advocate.