John Henwood

By John Henwood

WELL, I’m glad that’s over. Last year was not a particularly good one in any respect and a specially bad one in that I lost so many people who, in one way or another, had enriched my life at some point. Through the year far too many friends and valued associates passed away. As much as one tries not think about it, at my age it’s impossible not to reflect on one’s own mortality. That said, I’m lucky to be in reasonably good health and, despite the sadness that goes with the passing of old friends, I remain robustly enthusiastic and energetic. The trick is to direct the energy where it may be most effectively applied and to enjoy the pursuits which fire my enthusiasm, until the fuel runs out. There always seems so much to do that I hope the reserves are plentiful.

This column is never a chore, but at times I do get weary of the compulsion to highlight the shortcomings of government. It would be much more fun writing about successes than failures, but sadly the former have been few and far between. Indeed, having followed the recent series on the past year in retrospect in this newspaper, the main thing to lift the heart is absolutely nothing to do with either government or the wider States of Jersey. The greatest highlight of the year was the remarkable resilience of the people and their generosity of both spirit and pocket in supporting those in need in times of trouble.

Local charitable and volunteer organisations are generally far too busy doing what they do best to take the time to tell the rest of us about their work. I’m privileged to have had some small insights into the work of some of them and two thoughts keep repeating themselves. The first is one of admiration for those who give so much of themselves for so little in terms of material reward. If asked, most would say their reward is the satisfaction to be found in helping others, but all too often they go unrecognised. The second is the anger – yes, that’s the right word – that I feel when I see hard-pressed volunteer organisations being required, by default, to sweep up the problems that government should be attending to, but isn’t.

It is, frankly, disgraceful that government spends many millions every year on, for instance, a mega Communications Directorate and a much bigger cohort in the Chief Minister’s Department. And new appointments in Health, including a Freedom to Speak Up Guardian, are ridiculous and simply point to the weaknesses in existing management. Any chief executive worth his salt in the private sector would be shocked by the suggestion of such a position. It is a key element in leadership that anyone in an organisation has the freedom to speak up to anyone about anything without fear of retribution. If that’s not the case within HCS then it is a failure of leadership and no amount of new posts is going to solve the problem. The money being applied to these expensive and largely unnecessary positions could and should be applied instead to supporting the charitable and voluntary sectors where really valuable work is being done.

There was though a piece of common sense from government to start the year. It emerged from the Economic Development Department, which says it will not pursue the planned review of arm’s length organisations (ALOs). Some of the left-leaning States Members have always had a bee in their bonnet about these entities which, in some cases, have taken on the work previously undertaken by government. Jersey Finance, Jersey Telecom and Visit Jersey are all good examples. Previously each were activities within government which had responsibility for licensing, regulating and promoting their activities. Civil servants might be good at regulating, but tend to be deficient at promoting and as there is clear conflict between these activities it was regulating that got most attention and marketing that was largely overlooked. Without appointing ALOs to look after these sectors under a separate regulator, our finance industry would not be in the healthy state it is today; tourism would be a defunct industry (the States Tourism Department was, in its own words, “managing decline”) and JT would not be the progressive and valuable asset that it is today. Each has a board of directors whose role it is to determine strategic direction with responsibility for fiscal policy, governance, supporting and sanctioning management and all the other requirements that go with running a sound business. Each board is responsible to the shareholder, in this case the people of Jersey as personified in the Treasury Minister.

What these boards do not need is the rubberneckers of officialdom looking over their shoulders making sure they are doing a proper job. In truth they know much more about how a business should be run than those government apparatchiks who might be appointed to review their work.

The bottom line is this, if the Treasury Minister, acting always in the interest of the people, has reason to believe the chairman and board are not doing a good job he is in a position to facilitate their replacement.

All boards understand the shareholder is a key stakeholder and they serve at their owners’ discretion.

This is a small step in the right direction and should be followed by more lightening of the regulatory burden with which not only ALOs but all local enterprises must contend.