By Robert Surcouf
WHY have successive governments all failed to properly manage the property portfolio they are entrusted with on our behalf as taxpayers?
In the private sector, failure to maintain company assets would lead to serious repercussions for the board. All we seem to hear are proposals to start anew or commence some new consultation that is in some way going to be different to those that have occurred in the past. The list of properties owned by the States that have been allowed to deteriorate, often unoccupied with no appreciation of the eventual cost of this inaction, is a tragedy.
Since we moved to ministerial government, with the belief at the time that this would speed up decision-making and create efficiencies, it often feels like the exact opposite. So many ministers, since the roles were created, have failed to properly address the challenges we face. The failings also extend to their oversight of the state-owned enterprises (SOE) and arm’s-length organisations (ALO), with a few exceptions.
If we consider social housing, the portfolio that Andium took on was in a poor state and it lacked meaningful redevelopment going back many years. While not perfect, I believe Andium have been one of the few success stories under ministerial government in that they have managed a material updating of the housing stock. They now run a maintenance management system that allows them to better schedule updates and reduce the need for expensive emergency repairs. Sadly, this type of approach does not appear to find favour elsewhere within government.
For the last few decades, we have seen maintenance or upgrading of infrastructure and existing buildings postponed. The result is we now find ourselves with major infrastructure projects all required at the same time, housing stalled due to lack of drains and no new hospital.
We have had sites such as La Folie and St Saviour’s Hospital boarded up and deteriorating due to procrastination and Fort Regent likely to face a similar fate. In certain cases, these properties are already in the stewardship of SOE or ALO that are paying senior staff large salaries and bonuses. When many of these were spun off the aim was that they would be more efficient and able to address matters promptly but other than prompt salary rises and large bonuses there is not a lot that is positive to show compared to what happened pre the changes.
Past governments have, in many cases, failed to maintain proper oversight on SOE and ALO, though some failings are not necessarily the current management’s fault. JDC are now looking to demolish and restart building where their predecessors, the Waterfront Enterprise Board, developed a pool, cinema and other entertainment facilities that were built with only a short intended life. How could that have made sense and warranted the salary and bonuses that those individuals earned? Where was the oversight?
We all know the greatest fiasco must be the hospital. Over a decade ago there was a practical plan to redevelop Overdale and the General Hospital to provide a two-site option at a reasonable cost. Both sites had a long history of their respective use and the surrounding infrastructure had developed accordingly to support an emergency hospital at Gloucester Street and recuperation and after-care at Overdale. Continuing this by developing the sites and utilising the older hotel sites in Kensington Place was already being discussed and made perfect sense.
Sadly, there was then a decision to try to find a new single site, not easy in an island 9×5, and plans were eventually developed at Gloucester Street. These did not pass as they did not meet with planning guidance and there were concerns about setting a precedent. What precedent would be set? Any deviation from planning guidance was to provide a hospital for the entire Island, no one else was going to have such an argument. How many other people have applied to flood a valley after we approved Queen’s Valley?
A small push in the right direction by the JLF government and we could have had work start at the Gloucester site at a sensible price and with cheap finance. Sadly, they thought they could find another flat site and build it for less. They chose a site that was previously rejected as unsuitable and then changed the planning rules so they could pass what was going to look like a giant carbuncle on top of Westmount at a far higher price. Though priced, the delay of four years and the Ukraine war has seen the cost of building skyrocket, fixed price contracts are off the table and the rate of interest has shot up and re-costed that option would now be a non-starter.
We are at primarily the two-site option where we were over a decade ago but likely at four times the price, if we are lucky. This seems logical until you appreciate that the plan is for the acute unit, requiring easy ambulance access, to be at Overdale, not at the General, which has the infrastructure already in use and a clear site that you could start building on almost immediately as a first-phase replacing the most urgent facilities. Why make it more complicated?
Is there a boat in the morning? I might want to buy a ticket as things never seem to get better.
-
Robert Surcouf comes from a Jersey farming family, though his mother was Spanish and moved to Jersey in the 1960s. He became an accountant and now specialises in risk and enterprise management. A father of two school-age children, he still helps organise and participates in local motorsport events and was one of the founding members of Better Way 2022 before the last election. The views expressed are his own.

