Anne Southern

By Anne Southern

We are still reeling from the turmoil in the UK caused by the mini-budget – the ‘reverse Robin Hood’ budget, which gave thousands to the rich and little or nothing to the poor, frightened the markets and had to be abandoned. An interesting fact emerged from this – even without such unfair and undeliverable measures, Britain is the most unequal country in Europe apart from Bulgaria.

So where does that place Jersey? We have been attracting publicity in the UK media for welcoming tax-avoiding millionaires at the same time as needing four foodbanks, having a largely unseen problem of homelessness and a working population leaving in droves. As has been demonstrated clearly by Wilkinson and Pickett in The Spirit Level, the wellbeing of a society does not depend on its level of affluence but by its level of equality. And though it sometimes feels as if we are better off than in the UK, as eye-watering energy price increases have not hit us yet, and we have an apparently stable government that seems to be at least trying to tackle some of our major problems, people are becoming increasingly aware of the huge gap between the top 1% and the rest of us, while the government has abandoned the target of reducing income inequality. We are a divided society, with no sense of us ‘all being in it together’.

Most people have been fairly relaxed about our high-net-worth residents, perhaps buying into the claim (unsupported by hard evidence) that they do a lot for charity and contribute to providing employment on the Island. We might ask why people are in need of charity and whether we would rather the services of our plumbers, carpenters and builders were not monopolised by the rich.

But now their luxury residences are not just tucked away down country lanes. As we are seeing opulent residences that belong in Hollywood sprouting up and prime sites in popular bays being taken over, Islanders are getting restless. We are very unhappy that our access to Grève de Lecq has been limited. We miss the opportunity to visit restaurants on now privatised coastal sites.

And we also wonder how the rich get planning permission for monstrosities totally out of keeping with the Jersey vernacular when ordinary people can’t even replace their draughty windows. It merely adds insult to injury that some of these places lie empty, not just for part of the year, but in some cases permanently, while the owners who have moved on to warmer climes watch their assets – I won’t call them homes – become ever more valuable.

OK, the government is planning to do something about empty properties (but what?) There is to be a moratorium on new houses over 3,000sq-ft (the size of three family homes) and the number of high-net-worths is to be limited and they are to be asked to pay more tax – but still not as much as our home-grown millionaires. As they would be paying more than double in the UK we could surely ask them to pay a bit more. The proposed measures are a drop in the ocean in terms of tackling our real inequalities.

Why are there so many who rely not only on food banks, but have to go to charities for school uniforms and basic household appliances? I’ve heard a charity worker say, ‘Of course some people know all the tricks’, which to me implies a lack of respect for those who need help. Ten years ago, food banks were unheard of, yet now as long as these humiliating charities exist there will be no pressure to change.

Some people are unable to work, and for them there needs to be a generous safety net. But most people in need of help are working people, who need the dignity of receiving a wage that allows them to pay their way, and housing that is genuinely affordable. To buy a new ‘affordable’ one-bedroom flat, you would need a £37,000 deposit and two wages that are median or above – in other words, unaffordable by half the population.

In a recent States debate it was said that there was no need for rent control, as people could always apply for Income Support. If you are on Income Support you have to fill in a lengthy and obtrusive form, and you cannot benefit fully from any windfall such as a small legacy or bit of extra work that comes your way.

In the many statements of intent from ministers, and in the government plan, I see many long abstract nouns that sound positive, yet are empty of meaning. ‘Inequality’ is not one of them, however necessary tackling it is to make us a happy and healthy society; a society that will not come under attack from overseas media.