St Helier Constable Simon Crowcroft is expected to lodge an amendment to the 2019 Budget which, if approved, would drop the top rate of the tax from 20 to ten per cent.

The Chamber of Commerce, which has regularly opposed the tax, said that retail companies have been reluctant to invest in Jersey because of it.

Under proposals approved during the last Budget debate, retailers earning annual profits of more than £500,000 would be subject to the new retail tax of up to 20 per cent.

An attempt to halve the top rate by then-Senator Philip Ozouf resulted in a tied vote – meaning that the motion was not passed and the 20 per cent rate remained intact.

But Mr Crowcroft believes the Assembly should have a fresh debate on the subject and that the States should be doing more to support retailers.

He said: ‘I think the main concern is the effect on investment by large retailers.

‘The indications I have received are that the retail tax has dented the confidence of the large retailers in terms of investing.

‘I personally think town has been extremely resilient through the recession and I feel the Budget is an opportunity to do things that will help to keep retail investment positive.

‘I have heard that it has made the large businesses question whether they are being supported sufficiently by government.’

And Mr Crowcroft, who appeared before the Economic Affairs Scrutiny Panel yesterday, said he would like to see the parish given more delegated responsibility for the high street. Earlier this week, the JEP revealed that the Constable was considering calling for an empty commercial property tax to encourage landlords to rent their spaces.

During the hearing, he said that a number of empty shops – such as the vacant Next store – had already had rent paid up front and there was therefore no incentive for landlords to search for fresh tenants.

During a Scrutiny hearing earlier in the week, Treasury Minister Susie Pinel said the full impact of the retail tax would not be known until the end of the first year of its introduction but said she had seen ‘no evidence’ that it was reducing competition in the sector.

Eliot Lincoln, president of the Chamber of Commerce, said: ‘It was quite clear at the time that Treasury didn’t really know what the effect of it would be from an income perspective and on the businesses. For us to come in at 20 per cent without having done the impact analysis, we felt was high.

‘We know that there are a number of businesses who have considered and turned down the decision to come to Jersey.

‘I know that some of the larger local retailers have spent less on investment in their own business in terms of training and development. It has absolutely had an impact on our retailers.’

Chamber chief executive Murray Norton – who at the time of the last States debate was Assistant Economic Development Minister – said the Island had lost millions in inward investment, partly due to the retail tax.

During that debate, he revealed that a large UK company was considering investing £20 million into the economy but opted not to as the States debated the tax.

And now, Mr Norton has said other companies have turned down the opportunity to set up shop in Jersey.

‘In my former role I was privy to a great deal of work with regards to inward investment,’ he said. ‘At the time of the debate there were inward investors actively looking at opening businesses in Jersey and, for many reasons, the cost of doing business here was one of the main reasons they didn’t come to fruition.

‘The 20 per cent retail tax is one of those reasons. There were significant investors of several millions of pounds – they will be looking at things like a retail tax when making their decision.’

The 2019 Budget is due to be debated on Tuesday 4 December.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *