IF you had won the lottery as a child, what would you have wanted to buy? A pony? A trip to Disneyland? Enough sweets and chocolate to last a lifetime?
For one child taking part in research into poverty in Jersey, the answer was pillows and blankets. Another wanted medicine for their baby brother who was often ill.
These are among the answers that have stayed with Children’s Commissioner Dr Carmel Corrigan as her office publishes its first dedicated report on child poverty.
There are other examples: children returning pocket money because they know their mother is struggling; children who need new shoes but do not ask; young people already ruling out a future in the Island because they cannot imagine affording to live here.
The report – entitled Less Money, More Stress: Children’s everyday experiences of money and rights – describes a burden that can begin long before a child understands a household budget.
“These aren’t just the teenagers,” Dr Corrigan said, explaining that children as young as five or six are finding ways to cope with their families’ financial pressures.
“They are aware that everything is expensive – that housing is expensive, food is expensive, clothing is expensive. They’re very conscious and very aware of that.
“And that’s a stressful situation for children to be in all the time – and that stress will have ongoing effects.”

Appointed in March 2024, Jersey’s second Children’s Commissioner is serving a six-year term until 2030.
Her office’s new research, launched yesterday to mark World Children’s Day, asks the Island to look beyond its prosperous image and listen to children whose everyday lives tell a different story.
Conducted with childhood poverty specialists from the University of Lancashire, it involved 136 children and young people aged five to 18, from 15 settings across Jersey. Young co-researchers helped shape the questions, activities and recommendations.
The starting point was a statistic: according to household-income figures, 24% of Jersey’s children live in households below the relative poverty line, with income after rent below 60% of the median.
But even with such stark statistics, Dr Corrigan found that people still try to dispute whether the problem exists.
“Certainly in my experience of raising the issue of child poverty, you get quite a lot of pushback in Jersey,” she said.
People question the figures, the measure, or whether poverty in such an affluent island can really be called poverty at all, she explained.
Meanwhile, during consultation for her office’s strategic plan in 2024, financial pressures kept surfacing in conversations with children. Their voices were missing from the debate.
“One of the reasons for doing this is to actually raise awareness of the fact that children are growing up in poverty here,” explained Dr Corrigan.
It needs to be discussed “without blame, without shame, without embarrassment”.
That can be difficult in a place whose wealth is so central to its identity. Poverty looks different from the deprivation people may associate with poorer countries, explained Dr Corrigan, and local families may also work hard to conceal it.
Responses suggesting parents should shop more wisely, budget better or work harder only make that concealment more likely.
“But of course, child poverty is never a child’s fault,” Dr Corrigan says. “In the vast majority of cases, it’s not parents’ fault. It’s to do with systems and the structures that we build.”
The research follows those pressures through the ordinary business of childhood: eating lunch, seeing friends, studying, playing and spending time with family.

Some children described eating less because school meals had become more expensive. Others could not afford the bus fare to meet friends. Homes were too small to invite anyone over, or lacked a quiet place to study.
Sometimes, the response was simply to stop asking. Dr Corrigan explained: “One of the things that is most notable is that children are developing management or coping strategies – so they may need something for school, or need new shoes, but they won’t ask because they know their parents are struggling.
“Or their parents will give them money to buy a snack or something when they’re out, and they’ll give it back afterwards and not spend it because they know there’s a shortage of money.
“They don’t have bicycles, but they won’t ask because they know that they can’t afford them. They don’t go to clubs or activities because of the cost of either transport or attending, and they don’t ask – they design their own strategies to help manage and cope.”
Those small decisions accumulate. Poor nutrition and cold, damp housing affect health. Missing activities weakens friendships. Financial pressure can make it harder to concentrate at school and narrow the careers children believe are available to them.
Some young people talked about pursuing work that would pay enough to live in Jersey rather than the work they actually wanted to do, while others could not see their future here at all.
For Dr Corrigan, the harsh contrast between prosperity and financial hardship in Jersey can make exclusion particularly painful.
“Where you have very, very great wealth at one end, it’s very hard to be poor at the other,” she said.
“That creates almost a silence. It creates that hiding practice where they rely on friends, or they rely on close family to make up those small gaps – and it’s difficult then to actually name it.”
Employment does not necessarily provide an escape. The Children’s Commissioner is struck by how many parents below the poverty line are working, sometimes holding two jobs.
“I can’t say this factually, but I think families who were doing okay are now just falling below that line of doing okay in the recent cost of living hikes,” she said.
“The number of people below that line who are in employment – or even working two jobs – is remarkable.”
Children wanted their parents to earn more partly so they could be at home more. Some described spending time alone or looking after siblings while parents worked.
“The cost of housing is one of the main drivers of child poverty here,” said Dr Corrigan.
“When you couple that with the housing entitlement and qualification system, you have a cohort of families who have no choice but to be in unqualified accommodation – which we know is very often more expensive and poorer quality.”

Despite the complexity of the problem, children’s proposals to help were often straightforward: more parks, cheaper buses, free activities, homes with gardens where they could play.
One child wanted a free street festival celebrating Jersey cows, and free bicycle schemes featured heavily in suggestions from those living in places without regular buses.
“I was quite surprised at this, but having access to a bicycle in Jersey gives them just that little bit more freedom,” said Dr Corrigan.
Their suggestions show why involving children matters. Adults can identify broad problems while overlooking the details that determine whether a child can join in.
“What they really want is people to see them, recognise that they have specific rights, they have specific needs, and to actually listen to them about being addressed,” said Dr Corrigan.
Listening, however, must lead somewhere. Dr Corrigan welcomes measures to ease living costs and acknowledges substantial investment in children’s services.
Schools and charities, including food banks, are doing valuable work, she added, but questioned how much responsibility should rest with them.
“Ultimately, the standard of living for children, and the right to an adequate standard of living, that’s an obligation on the state. That’s an obligation on the government.”
Her central demand is a coherent plan across government – bringing together housing, education, health, social security and other services, with clear targets and regular measurement.
“The UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights specifically recommended that Jersey look at a plan or a strategy for the reduction of child poverty – and that recommendation has not been accepted by the government,” she explained.
“We would like to see that recommendation accepted, and we would like to see a coherent cross-government plan or strategy for the reduction and ultimate eradication of child poverty.”
Measures outlined in the government’s proposed Budget are “welcomed”, she added, but too “siloed”.
“Measures in the Budget and what’s in the Common Strategic Policy are largely around either payments or school meals,” said Dr Corrigan.
“But we know from international research that employability matters, early years provision and adequate social security are three of the main prongs to address child poverty.
“That’s not to say the government has done nothing in any of those areas, but there is no strategy for it. There is no plan. There are no reduction targets. There’s no regular measurement.”
Measuring household incomes roughly every five or six years leaves long gaps in understanding children’s lives.
“A lot can happen in the development of children in five years,” noted Dr Corrigan.
Her office wants Statistics Jersey adequately funded to build a fuller, more frequent picture.
“How do we know if we’re reducing it if we’re not measuring it?” she asked. “It won’t end by filling in small gaps here and there; it’s a policy choice.”

And her response to any minister who might say there is no money is direct.
“I think the spending money all depends on whose priorities you want to put at the top of your list. If you want to put children at the top of your list, then reducing and ending child poverty should be amongst your top priorities.
“I believe money can be found from other areas that, although are maybe necessary, may not be as immediate, or may not have the long-term impact that the lack of investment in this will have – and it will have long-term impacts.”
She outlined some of those impacts: “Growing up in poverty is not a prediction of a lesser adulthood, but it is a prediction of additional challenges.
“We know that there are very well-proven overlaps between that and adult issues – mental health, physical health, a crossover into the criminal justice system.
“These things are known. Jersey is not the only jurisdiction that is going to be able to escape them by doing nothing.
“I really do think that if you want to secure your future, you have to secure your present, and that to me is why child poverty needs to be addressed.
“No child in Jersey should ever, for the want of money, go to bed or go to school hungry. This is not about blaming parents. It’s not about blaming individuals, and it’s certainly not about blaming children.”
In the short term, her priorities include progress towards a poverty strategy, better measurement and expanded school meals, including a secondary-school pilot.
“If you don’t have enough to eat at 11, the chances are you don’t have enough to eat at 12.
“Poverty doesn’t end at the primary school gates; it will follow children into secondary school, and so that needs to be robustly piloted and, I would suspect, extended.”
But first, Jersey must become more comfortable naming the problem.
“The most significant thing for me is to start this conversation in a much more comfortable space, because if we don’t name it, we can’t address it.
“So we need to name it, and we need to take away any kind of blame on children, any kind of blame on parents who are, as I say, just trying to make ends meet.”
“This is one of the most fundamental rights a child has because it’s linked to virtually every other right.
“If you don’t have an adequate standard of living, your right to survive, thrive, and develop is under pressure from the very beginning. So this is pretty fundamental.”

