Royal Court building, Royal Square, St Helier 7/9/26 Picture: ROB CURRIE

A 20-YEAR-OLD man accused of rape has told jurors that he “wasn’t sure” whether his alleged victim was engaged in “consensual non-consent” roleplaying when she told him to stop having sex with her.

James Anthony Dubras, who denies allegations of rape, attempted rape and sexual penetration without consent, continued his evidence yesterday at the Royal Court.  

Under cross-examination from Crown Advocate Lauren Hallam, prosecuting, the Islander said that he had halted sexual intercourse with the complainant upon hearing her say that she wanted to stop.

But he accepted that, despite this, he then immediately asked her if they could continue.

“Why did you ask again?”, Crown Advocate Hallam enquired.

“Because earlier on that evening she had seemed very confident that we could do it, ” Mr Dubras replied. “And so I didn’t know the reason at the time as to why she’d said stop.”

Jurors previously heard the defendant suggest that he thought his alleged victim might have been encouraging him to engage in “consensual non-consent” roleplaying.

“I wasn’t sure why she’d withdrawn consent,” he repeated yesterday, before reiterating that he thought it could have been an example of “consensual non-consent”.

The prosecutor put to Mr Dubras that he had not mentioned “anything” about consensual non-consent in his defence statement.

“Are you just making this up to explain your own bad behaviour?”, she asked.

“No, I didn’t make it up”, the defendant responded.

The prosecutor then put to him that, after the alleged rape, he attempted to rape the complainant again before sexually assaulting her.

She stated that he had tried to “manipulate” the woman, and had even admitted to being “pushy” with her throughout the night in question.

But Mr Dubras insisted that his “pushiness” had not escalated to the serious sexual offences alleged.

The complainant was then recalled to answer questions about Mr Dubras’ evidence concerning “consensual non-consent”.

“What is your understanding of what it means?”, Crown Advocate Hallam asked.

“A fetish for roleplaying a rape scenario agreed beforehand with a safe word that means stop,” she replied.

She then confirmed to the court that she was not “personally interested” in this practice and had never engaged in it with the defendant.

The court next heard a character witness statement written by Mr Dubras’ partner, in which she described him as “kind”, “compassionate” and “very patient”.

“He has never made me uncomfortable, or pressured me into doing something which I did not want him to do,” she said. “I have always felt comfortable with James.”

The Deputy Bailiff, Mark Temple, is presiding. The trial, which is scheduled to last one week, continues.