A BACKBENCH politician has followed criticism of the way ministers brought forward their Common Strategic Policy document by bringing forward her own proposals for a different approach to be adopted in future.
Outlining ministerial policies for the forthcoming political term, the CSP document was passed by the Assembly last week, including the majority of 25 amendments put forward by States Members.
But ten politicians voted against the policy roadmap for the years 2027-2030, with another two abstaining, and there was a call for change from Deputy Hilary Jeune, chair of the Environment, Housing and Infrastructure Scrutiny panel.
Deputy Jeune, one of the group to vote against, said that the effect of the way the government had lodged the CSP for debate was to blur the lines between government and scrutiny.
“It’s either the government’s plan, or the Assembly’s, and that matters for accountability,” she said. “This is a document that’s been written by the executive for the executive and then put to the Assembly as if it belongs to all of us.”
Within 24 hours of the conclusion of the three-day CSP debate, the representative for St John, St Lawrence and Trinity had lodged a proposition that in future the CSP would have to be lodged as a report within four months of a new Council of Ministers being formed. After a minimum of six weeks for Scrutiny, the Assembly would hold an “in-committee” debate, without a vote at the end.
The proposal would also require an update to be issued by 31 January every year, charting progress against each of the priorities, with measurable indicators where possible.
In the report accomanying her proposition, Deputy Jeune said backbench politicians had been offered a one hour briefing on the CSP, with a 90-minute workshop subsequently added following pressure from the Corporate Services panel.
“The CSP is the Council of Ministers’ agreement, not the Assembly’s,” she said. “It should be published, presented, debated and scrutinised.
“But non-executive Members did not negotiate it or draft it and had little chance to shape it – asking them to approve it treats them as co-authors of a plan they had almost no hand in.
“If the Assembly is going to be asked to own a plan, it should be involved in building it. Until that happens, the plan should be presented as the government’s own, and the Assembly should hold ministers to account against it.”
The proposition will be debated at a forthcoming sitting of the Assembly.

