A SENIOR backbencher has hit out at ministers’ delaying tactics over new whistleblowing legislation, saying there is an even greater need for the measure than when it was unanimously supported by the States Assembly more than three years ago.
Deputy Carina Alves, chair of the Privileges and Procedures Committee, said she would be emphatically rejecting an attempt by the Council of Ministers to delay the date for the new law to be brought forward.
She cited recent controversy over an ongoing employment tribunal in which former safeguarding partnership lead Alison Renouf claims she was sacked from her position for whistleblowing by leaking details of a meeting in which senior government officials discussed child safety and the Independent Jersey Care Inquiry. The States Employment Board, which acts as the employer for public sector staff, contends that she was dismissed for gross misconduct.
A proposition lodged by Deputy Alves, due to be debated by States Members later this week, requires the government to bring forward the new legislation by 31 January next year. Ministers responded with an amendment which – if supported – would move the date back to January 2028.
“The recent case highlights the urgency for this law to be brought into force,” she said. “It shows that if people don’t feel safe to stand up and act then they won’t say anything .
“There seems to be a feeling in some elements of society that it’s better to keep quiet, and that why people who want to do the right thing are frowned upon, which is outrageous – it shouldn’t take something like this for action to be taken.”
Ministers stated that they saw benefit in “further consultation with key stakeholders, including employers, employee representatives and HR professionals”, but Deputy Alves rejected this suggestion.
“There has already been ample consultation on this,” she said. “It bothers me when a new government comes in and has already started trying to do more consultation – it’s just another delaying tactic.
“I realise there’s been an election, but what have officials been doing since the report for the new law was published in March?”
The matter originally came before the Assembly in July 2023, when a proposition by Deputy Alves won unanimous support. Preparatory work for the new law stalled after the change of government in early 2024, and then in March of this year it was published as a report, with no time for a debate prior to the election in June.
If the ministerial amendment is successful, Deputy Alves said she believed it could be up to two years before the law comes into force, allowing time for scrutiny, the Assembly debate and a wait until the “appointed day” when legislation would actually enter the statute book.
“What sort of message does this [attempt to delay] send to our public service employees?” she asked.

