Sir Mark Boleat, senator and Minister for Planning and Regulation 23/7/26 Picture: ROB CURRIE

JERSEY’S planning system is imposing excessive costs, obstructing economic growth and giving too much weight to preserving the past, according to a government-commissioned report co-written by the man who is now Planning Minister.

The £10,250 review calls for sweeping cuts to paperwork, faster decisions, smaller minimum housing sizes and tighter restrictions on neighbours’ rights to appeal against developments.

Prepared for Policy Centre Jersey by Sir Mark Boleat and Alan Merry, it was completed before Sir Mark’s election as a Senator and appointment as Planning Minister.

Published on Friday, the report argued that much of the burden comes from guidance, conditions and administrative procedures rather than legislation.

“The whole planning system attempts to do too much, covering not only planning but a wide range of social and economic issues which it is not well suited to do,” it said.

“It takes little account of costs imposed by the system and gives inadequate weight to other public policy objectives.”

The authors described the Bridging Island Plan as “unduly restrictive, emphasising preservation of the past rather than facilitating the future”.

They also accused planning requirements of being “gold plated”, saying applicants must supply documents for which there is no justification within the plan.

A 21-page validation document lists 55 separate requirements, some applying to all applications and others to particular developments. The report says these are often unnecessarily onerous, especially for smaller schemes.

It recommends removing requirements for noise and crime impact assessments, relaxing demands for ecological and tree surveys, and substantially raising the thresholds at which transport statements and travel plans are needed.

Minor applications should normally be supported by annotated photographs rather than drawings, while developers should be allowed to certify their own compliance with planning conditions.

The authors also challenge the weight given to heritage protection.

“Undue weight is given to heritage issues at the expense of viability and other considerations,” they stated.

They argued that the development brief for St Saviour’s Hospital prevents viable redevelopment, citing Andium’s estimate that converting Queen’s House would cost approximately £8.4 million more than the resulting homes would be worth.

On housing standards, the report said Jersey’s higher minimum requirements remove choice from people seeking smaller homes. It recommended cutting the timeframe for minor planning decisions from eight weeks to six, with an eventual four-week target, and major applications from 12 weeks to nine.

Appeals should be lodged within seven days rather than 28. The authors also propose reducing the distance within which qualifying neighbours can appeal from 50 metres to 30, with consideration of abolishing third-party appeals once confidence in the system improves.

The report acknowledges significant improvements in planning services. Its research involved discussions with a limited number of participants, without a general call for evidence.

The government said its findings were being considered alongside other evidence and advice. The authors received no personal payment.