A JERSEY doctor has sounded the alarm over the Island’s weak prescribing controls for off-license weight-loss drugs – warning that financial incentives could be driving irresponsible use and putting patients at risk.
Dr Chris Edmond spoke to the JEP following a three-day series in which this newspaper explored the growing use of weight loss drugs in Jersey and the need for a more holistic approach to weight management.
During the series, Islanders who had used surgical and medical interventions to help them lose weight called for more psychological support in Jersey.
Jersey Eating Disorder Support chief executive Karen Dingle said that people “absolutely” need to be more aware of the mental impact of significant weight loss.
And Jersey Bariatric Surgery Support Group co-founder Helen Treby said there is a “severe lack of psychological support” in the Island.
“The States pay for surgery, which myself and so many people are grateful for, however they do not provide psychological support which can cause patients more issues further down the line,” she said.
“Surgery is a tool that helps you lose weight, however it doesn’t alter your brain.”
Dr Edmond, who is the co-founder and chair of a not-for-profit organisation helping Islanders improve their health through lifestyle changes, has now added to those calls.
“I think the the pharmaceutical industry has got somewhat ahead of the support that we should be providing for people,” he said.
“Weight-loss drugs are a good solution, but they don’t work without lifestyle change.”
He also raised broader concerns about the lack of local oversight and regulation for GLP-1 receptor agonists – a group of drugs that includes Mounjaro and Ozempic.
“It’s a little bit like our local cannabis industry,” said Dr Edmond. “There is not enough control.
“When there’s financial benefit for the doctors or health services prescribing these things, then the controls tend to be a lot more lax.
“People will tend to prescribe far more easily because there’s a financial imperative to do so.
“Doctors are as fallible as anyone else when it comes to making money, unfortunately.”
Another major issue, he warned, is inappropriate access to the medication.
“We don’t have the safety evidence for young people and, for people of normal weight, we’re just encouraging eating disorders to develop and supporting them,” he said.
Dr Edmond also questioned the quality and consistency of prescribing services.
“I think some some of the services that have cropped up to prescribe these medications have been very good and have offered some of that wraparound support – but not nearly enough, because it’s actually quite complicated and quite hard to deliver.
“For long-term lifestyle change, you’ve got to support people in understanding their eating habits and increase their exercise and access to sort of better community facilities.
“It’s got to be a longer term programme than just: ‘Here’s an injection. Off you go!'”
He therefore called for weight-loss drugs to be offered as “part of a much more holistic package of care”.
“The government should be investing in supportive services – be they delivered by not for profits or charities or by the health service themselves,” he said.
“It’s very short-sighted to just give people an injection and say ‘away you go,’ because it’s not sustainable.
Dr Edmond emphasised that weight-loss drugs are highly effective and show faster results than past methods, but pointed out that governments have consistently underfunded proper preventative lifestyle services – both in the UK and locally.
“The government has to invest,” he said.
“We need to develop local resources like health coaching and psychological support for people, so that people don’t have to reach for medication as the first thing they go for.
“It’s not a long term solution – it has got to be part of the wider policy thing.
“We’ve got to be looking at how the supermarkets sell food, we’ve got to look at access to local food, we’ve got to look at potential controls on selling junk food and having chocolate bars near checkouts and all of those things that are in the UK government’s food strategy.
“I know our local Public Health team are looking at it – but we have to get a move on.”
- Read Dr Edmond’s opinion piece on page 18 of JEP Weekend.

