Overdale is one of four locations proposed for the Island’s new healthcare facilities Picture: DAVID FERGUSON

JERSEY’S new healthcare facilities are unlikely to be any cheaper than the £800 million Our Hospital scheme, which was rejected partly amid concerns over its price, the Infrastructure Minister has said.

Deputy Tom Binet admitted during States questions yesterday that the sharp rise in inflation, and the fact that the new project included more health facilities than the former scheme, had pushed up the overall cost.

Under new plans released by ministers last month, which will be put before the States later this year, health services would be based at Overdale, Kensington Place and Gloucester Street, St Saviour’s Hospital and at the former Les Quennevais School.

The scheme would replace plans for a hospital at Overdale.

Deputy Binet has repeatedly stressed the need for Jersey’s new healthcare facilities to be affordable after ministers ditched the Our Hospital project led by Deputy Lyndon Farnham.

Speaking last September, Deputy Binet said that Our Hospital was ‘no longer feasible’ and that research into a ‘more affordable and appropriate’ alternative was essential.

Infrastructure Minister Tom Binet

Two months later, when ministers formally announced plans to drop the Overdale scheme, Deputy Binet said that the decision was ‘unlikely to please everyone’ but that it offered the ‘best chance of achieving the high-quality future hospital facilities which the Island needs, but in a way that is both affordable and achievable in the shortest possible timescales’.

Several backbench politicians lined up to grill Deputy Binet during the opening moments of yesterday’s sitting, with the cost of the latest multi-site scheme being the dominant theme.

Deputy Montfort Tadier referred to previous comments from ministers that the budget for the project would not be released for reasons of commercial sensitivity.

He said: ‘Is the real reason [no cost figure has been given] because the Council of Ministers and this minister don’t know it, not because of commercial sensitivity?’

Deputy Binet responded: ‘The project is at a very early stage. When it comes to it, I will be transparent but at this stage, I am not sufficiently confident that it is accurate enough for me to release a figure.’

When Deputy Sam Mézec queried the ‘alleged unaffordability’ of the previous scheme, Deputy Binet said there were significant differences between the two concepts.

‘This [new] scheme is a different one, covering an extra 30,000 square metres and taking into account the many things that the Our Hospital project didn’t,’ he said.

‘With double-digit inflation, it is highly unlikely that it will come in below the sum that was pencilled in at a very early stage for Our Hospital.’

Infrastructure Minister Tom Binet

Deputy Binet said he could not give an exact date when more detailed price information would be available but that he hoped to do so later this week. He committed to seeking States Assembly approval before commencing work, but declined to specify whether this would be as part of the Government Plan debate scheduled for December, or in a dedicated debate.

‘I will be bringing it [to the Assembly] in a way that proves acceptable to Members,’ he said.

During yesterday’s sitting, Deputy Farnham estimated that the additional scale of the latest project, combined with double-digit inflation, could lead to a price tag of between £1.2bn and £1.4bn, adding: ‘It is quite right that a capital project of this size is brought to the Assembly for approval before the money is committed.’

Later in the sitting, Treasury Minister Ian Gorst warned that the government had previously ‘almost touted around’ the amount it was willing to pay for capital projects.

‘What then happens is all bids come in either at that price or, in the case of the Our Hospital project, well above that price.

‘There will be a point where those things can be published but we need to do more work before we do that,’ he continued.