Deputy Jeremy Maçon Picture: ROB CURRIE

PARISH hall hustings will continue to be filmed and streamed online if politicians back a bid to block ‘unacceptable’ plans to only video special pre-election meetings in the States Chamber.

Deputy Jeremy Maçon has lodged a proposition which, if approved, would request the Privileges and Procedures Committee to film and stream ‘conventional hustings meetings’ in June and at subsequent elections. In previous elections, hustings held at parish venues have been filmed and streamed online at vote.je.

But the PPC recently confirmed plans to host online hustings in the States Chamber and said that vote.je would not be providing recording equipment for the parish hall roadshow.

PPC chairwoman Deputy Carina Alves said that candidates who wished to hold in-person hustings at parish halls would have to meet the associated costs themselves.

This year’s election marks the first under new reforms to the composition of the States, with the Islandwide Senatorial mandate having been scrapped in favour of nine constituencies from which Deputies will be chosen, alongside the 12 parish Constables.

Deputy Maçon said: ‘The filming of hustings is a centrally approved resource provided by the States Assembly. PPC has decided to change this without referring this proposal back to the Assembly – reducing the budget allocation for this work and then using the money to do work elsewhere without States Assembly approval. This is despite the fact that the Assembly specifically authorised the web streaming of hustings.

‘The forced online provision, in the States Assembly, removes the ability of candidates to choose the rules of their hustings or how they operate. It’s a take-it-or-leave-it offering from PPC. This is unacceptable. If candidates do not want to use the provision in the States Assembly, they then lose the chance of any funding for filmed and uploaded hustings.’

However, Deputy Alves said the original hustings format was a ‘little tired’. In response to a recent written States question from Deputy Maçon, she said that the new proposals were ‘Covid proof’ and would result in a ‘considerable cost saving’.

‘The rationale for the proposed changes was to try to broaden the reach of these valuable events. It was therefore decided that for 2022 we would offer candidates the chance to attend live broadcast hustings to which the public could submit questions both in advance and in real time,’ she said.

‘There was no direct consultation in relation to the filming arrangements apart from with the Jersey Electoral Authority. There is no legal requirement for the hustings to be filmed.

‘PPC is not stopping candidates from holding additional hustings in parish halls or community spaces. We want to make the events as accessible as possible and we believe that the proposed way forward will only increase public engagement in the hustings process.’

Deputy Maçon has questioned the suitability of the newly proposed format.

‘It’s bizarre to have a situation whereby PPC has confirmed that hustings are the responsibility of the candidates but then wishes to impose its own model for hustings, with the associated allocated funding, with no consultation or States Assembly approval and remove a centrally funded resource for those who do not wish to use this format,’ he said.

The Deputy’s proposition is due to be debated on 25 April.