Dr Amar Alwitry had his job offer rescinded before he was due to start work at the Hospital in 2012, with the States putting it down to a breakdown in their relationship with him.
Mr Alwitry disputed this and in the eight years since the two have been locked in a legal battle.
Now the consultant ophthalmologist looks likely to receive substantial damages after an application by the States Employment Board for leave to appeal was dismissed.
The doctor won his case in February 2019 against the SEB, when the Royal Court found he had been unlawfully dismissed in breach of contract following a two-week trial.
The decision to sack him was also described by the States Complaints Board in 2016 as ‘one of the worst examples’ of a public authority ‘disregarding’ contract law.
The SEB have since applied for leave to appeal, but it was dismissed by the Court of Appeal before they took the case to the Privy Council.
The Queen, on the advice of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, refused permission at a meeting of the Privy Council held during lockdown at Windsor Castle on 3 April.
A statement from St John’s Chambers, which represented the doctor in his legal battle, said: ‘The decision is a significant one, recognising at the highest judicial level that the right of the SEB as employer to dismiss Jersey consultants on notice without cause has been fettered by the express terms of their contract.’
Also in the statement the law firm states that Mr Alwitry’s claim to damages is not capped by reference to any notice period.
Previously the doctor had estimated that his total claim could amount to £8 million in damages.
A spokeswoman for the government said that £140,000 had been spent on external legal fees for the case since 2017, with most of the work on the case done internally by the Law Officers’ Department.’

