About 700 Islanders marched from the site at the Esplanade car park to the Royal Square, chanting ‘Enough is enough’, ‘Stop wasting our money’ and ‘Can you hear us now?’.

The chants were aimed at the Council of Ministers, who were accused by many of the protesters of failing to listen to their concerns.

It is the second time this year that a large number of Islanders have taken part in a protest against the scheme, which is being handled by the States-owned Jersey Development Company.

In June, around 2,000 people formed a ring of defiance around the site.

The crowd gathered in front of the States Building to voice their displeasure with the project and to express their view that States Members are not listening to them.

Malcolm RayMarie Jenkins

Malcolm Ray: ‘I hope that apathy hasn’t set in after June and people don’t accept it as a fait accompli. We still need to send out a message to States Members that we haven’t forgotten about it. I haven’t spoken to anyone who thinks it is a good idea. If enough people get behind things like this, we can make a difference.’

Marie Jenkins: ‘We need to protest against the fact that they are just going ahead with their plans. I hope the States start listening. They are elected members but I haven’t voted for any of this. We have to keep trying to do something to prevent this.’

Willy NieuwburgJacqui Carrel

Willy Nieuwberg: ‘Most of us know that we need a robust finance industry, but the way the JDC and the politicians have gone about this has destroyed all trust in them. There is already a finance centre, so why bother doing this now? If any finance house needs new offices, they will do it, so why are they risking our money to build this?

ANYONE who thought that public concern, and in some quarters anger, about the Jersey International Finance Centre had fizzled out now that building has begun is mistaken. That much was proved by the number of people who turned out yesterday to march through St Helier and demand that the Council of Ministers listen to their concerns.

The debate has become yet more polarised, but there must be something which all sides should be able to agree on. If this scheme is being pursued in the public interest, then the public should be privy to the information on which that judgment has been made. And if that is not possible because of commercial sensitivity, then confidence should come through the safeguards of the Scrutiny process.

Islanders want reassurance that they are not being led down a financial dead end.

And yet the calls for transparency and openness have resulted in yet more confusion and obfuscation.

In the spring, the Treasury commissioned global property experts DTZ to review the scheme and offer an estimate for the return it could deliver the taxpayer.

Only part of that report has been released, including the bit which said that the finance centre could generate a profit of up to £95 million if all six blocks were constructed and all were fully let and sold.

The Corporate Services Scrutiny Panel have also commissioned a report, theirs by accountants EY, looking at some of the same questions which go to the heart of public concern.

It concluded that the six-building scheme would not generate enough to pay for the promised underground car parking and parks, and would not return the £50 million that ministers have long said that the scheme would bring into the Treasury. Echoing one of the key issues which brought the demonstrators out yesterday, EY also questioned demand for office space. The accountants did, however, find that building 4 (which is under construction) and 5 should go ahead.

What are Islanders supposed to think? Ordinary, responsible people who want a prosperous and sustainable finance industry for many years to come, but have little faith in a States quango to deliver it.

Ministers and the Jersey Development Company want certainty and stability because that is what gives confidence to potential tenants. What they fail to realise is that their refusal to disclose documents, even on a confidential basis, to Scrutiny makes that more difficult than ever.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *