Today the findings of a serious-case review have been published following the death of the man, known only as Mr H, who died while living in a care home in 2013.
Serious-case reviews are carried out by the Safeguarding Adults Partnership Board when abuse or neglect of an adult is known or suspected and the individual has died or been seriously harmed and there is serious concern about the way that agencies have worked together.
As part of his care at the home, Mr H, who often refused medication, had antibiotics placed into his food without his knowledge to help him fight a chest infection, as he was suffering from bronchopneumonia.
While the covert administration of medication is not unusual in such situations, concerns were raised by the Health Department’s Adult Safeguarding team about whether there had been a proper assessment of Mr H’s mental capacity to see whether he could make his own decision about taking the antibiotics.
Following this, the covert administration of the medicine was stopped, but Mr H went on to refuse medication when given the choice. Five days later he died from bronchopneumonia.
Six recommendations have now been made by the board in the hope that lessons can be learned and policies and procedures improved.
The chairwoman of the Safeguarding Partnership Board, Glenys Johnston, said: ‘This case involved a complex man who did not like doctors and never took medication.
‘Consequently, his care gave rise to considerable challenges for those looking after him. The findings do make it clear that staff at the residential care home and other professionals provided good care to Mr H.
‘However, the review also indicates a lack of clear strategy for making decisions about this gentleman’s care and the assessment of his mental capacity.’
The Safeguarding Partnership Board’s review has recommended that Mr H’s case should be used in training across a number of healthcare bodies in the Island, that legislation behind Jersey’s codes of practice and policies relating to mental capacity be looked at as a matter of urgency and that the Hospital’s discharge plan informs the care planning for care home residents.
A so-called learning report that accompanied the review also calls for treatment administered by care homes to be ‘explicitly associated’ with medical diagnoses, that care home residents with complex needs are given care managers and that a ‘refresh’ of adult safeguarding policies and procedures is undertaken.
The review said that the Adult Safeguarding team were appropriately involved when concerns were raised, but that their focus had been on the process used to deal with Mr H.
The learning report said: ‘The GP was not included in the key strategy review meeting and decisions implemented following this meeting meant that Mr H’s condition deteriorated. He died five days after the initial meeting.’
Mrs Johnston added that the review was not designed to apportion blame, but to ensure that lessons were learned and training and working practice improved.
‘The Safeguarding Adults Partnership Board and its member agencies will do everything they can to support services in implementing change and providing training to assist staff and ensure best practice guidance is followed,’ she said.

