When it first made an appearance on our screens at the end of 2011 I got the sense that it lacked something, but it wasn’t until its re-emergence five weeks ago that I realised what it was. Jersey. Jersey was missing.

With opening shots of a paddleboarder and surfers, it starts promisingly enough, but quickly descends into a rather peculiar guide not to our tourist attractions, but to some of the people who live here.

We meet a semi-naked ‘water sports enthusiast’, then some people following tour guide Arthur Lamy up a path, followed by two children running (presumably) through Mont Orgueil Castle, followed by artist Nicholas Romeril and his dog, then a quick shot of some sand before we see Nerina Pallot playing her guitar in a camper van.

It’s a nice advert, and brilliantly conveys a message that Jersey is a friendly little place.

But break the advert down into sections and it is obvious that all it does is establish that Jersey has paddleboarders, surfers, at least one artist, at least one tour guide and at least one sandy beach.

But what’s the point of promoting the fact that we have artists and tour guides? Everywhere has got artists and tour guides.

It is perhaps a mark of how uninspiring the advert is that, at the time of writing this column, the most recent comment on its YouTube page simply said: ‘Such lovely music’.

Such lovely music? What about the beautiful bays, the castles and the stunning countryside? What about the jaw-dropping views across the water to France? Or the equally spectacular sight of Sark rising high from the sea which only someone who has trodden the north coast on a fine day can truly appreciate?

What about the Royal Square or the quite unusual fusion of French meets quaint English countryside that is Jersey’s network of green lanes?

All this is sadly absent from this so-called promotion of what is undoubtedly a truly fantastic tourist destination.

And what makes it worse is that it is rounded off with factually correct but rather ineffective strapline of ‘Jersey – the warmest place in the British Isles’.

We may be a couple of degrees warmer, but it means pretty much nothing when Britain is renowned for being cold and wet. It is essentially saying: ‘Jersey – slightly less cold that where you live.’

Compare this to some of the recent television adverts promoting our rival destinations and it is clear to see where we have gone so very wrong.

Take, for example, the Surprise Yourself Visit Scotland advert, which rolls out every one of its big hitters – castles, mountains, lochs, beaches, woodland, coastal villages, golf courses and whisky – to leave viewers in no doubt that the country has a lot to offer.

Meanwhile, our big hitters – from Mont Orgueil Castle and Durrell to St Brelade’s Bay and the War Tunnels – are nowhere to be seen.

Not surprisingly, the advert, which was reintroduced for a short period around Christmas and is apparently due to get another showing this month, failed to turn on potential holidaymakers last year, and for that reason it is hard to see what it is going to do for the Island in 2013.

Overall, visitor numbers last year were down 3.8 per cent compared to 2011, and have plummeted by almost a third over the last decade.

Although the London Olympics and the Queen’s Jubilee undoubtedly didn’t help Tourism’s cause, it is now clear that the industry needs a major change of direction when it comes to marketing.

Let us hope, then, that the new shadow tourism board, to be made up of industry experts from Jersey, the UK and elsewhere, will finally set the Island on a more positive path because, despite the economic problems and the ever-increasing competition from elsewhere, there is something very wrong when a place like Jersey can continue to suffer year-on-year drops in visitor figures.

The board’s leader – former Jersey Telecom chairman John Henwood – was appointed last week and was keen to stress that the industry’s fortunes rested on the modernisation of a marketing strategy that had hardly changed since the boom era of the 1970s.

Although stopping short of criticising Jersey Tourism, which he said had ‘made good progress in certain areas’, he nevertheless stated that there would be benefits in starting ‘with a clean sheet of paper’.

And it is important that the shadow board is given time to draw up an action plan. The industry is so wounded after so many years of decline that any attempt to revive it is going to be slow. Another drop in visitor figures this year should not be seen as a failure for the board, not least because what should be the shop window of the delights of Jersey – the TV advert – fails to include a single tourist attraction.

But while it is likely that this year will be another struggle, there is perhaps now some hope for the future. After all, if the people who make a living from this industry can’t turn around its fortunes, then who can?

And let’s hope that, regardless of anything else they do for the industry, they start by creating a television advert which actually features some of the staggering number of tourist attractions crammed into this little Island.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *