People vote for them because they are good speakers and communicators, because their confidence is infectious and because they met the voters, listened to them and chatted to them. Politicians are, by their very nature, ‘people persons’.

With that in mind, one might assume that to be one of Jersey’s 51 States Members is a sociable experience.

There are a lot of them, for a start, and one can imagine that when they all get together outside the States Chamber it’s a bit like the first night in the Big Brother house, where big personalities and characters test each other’s patience and engage in healthy debate and conversation.

This may be the case if and when such a get-together takes place. But more often than not, it doesn’t. Instead, Jersey currently has 51 ‘people persons’ who thrive on conversation, meeting people and working together who lead entirely separate and often lonely existences.

Now this situation – which has been confirmed by a number of States Members both past and present, the most recent one this week – is surprising, because you would imagine that to be part of the House (the political one, not the Big Brother one) is a bit like being part of a club or, at the very least, a workplace where you are all ultimately working towards the same goals.

But if you discount the States Chamber because it is only really used twice a month, unlike a club or a workplace there is no central headquarters. You can’t just pop over to your colleague’s desk for a quick chat, mingle by the water cooler or arrange to leave the office en masse on a Friday evening for the pub.

In an office, even if you don’t particularly like some of your colleagues, in many cases you still have some kind of daily interaction with them, and most of us probably don’t realise how important that actually is.

It is often said that being a stay-at-home parent, working from home or being out of work altogether is a lonely experience. But so, too, is being a politician. Of course, ministers are slightly different in that they have a support team around them and an office environment in which to work. Being part of a clique also helps, as that acts as a kind of de facto political party.

But for everyone else – even those who are members of various panels, working parties and groups – their working lives can be a solitary experience.

This situation is of course made worse, if not totally caused, by the lack of political parties in Jersey. But in their absence (that in itself is a debate for another day), it is a situation that has a number of implications.

The first is that no matter how much we talk about joined-up politics, about working together and about constructive engagement, it cannot truly happen. It also makes it a lot harder work to get anywhere near those ideals.

Secondly, it puts added pressure on politicians and may even put some of them off standing again altogether.

Thirdly, it compounds the feeling, real or perceived, that there are ‘insiders and outsiders’ in the States, that ministers are our government and that backbenchers are the opposition.

Of course, if a politician is neither of these , it can alienate them further. And challenging people on your own, or getting things done on your own, is no easy task.

Of course, there are things that politicians can do to ease the pressures of this situation. They can make themselves go out, talk to people, meet people, organise lunches, dinners, drinks and so on. They can attend all the briefings, meetings and events to which they are invited. And they can channel their energies into engaging with their constituents.

The system ,too, can (and is likely to) change during the next few years as the Electoral Commission comes up with a new way of working. Some will say that having fewer States Members will help, but that will only be the case if those fewer people are given more to do in environments where they are allowed to be the social beings that they are.

But until then, there are other things that can happen. For example, St Helier Constable Simon Crowcroft, when standing for the role of chairman of Privileges and Procedures last year, suggested reintroducing States Members’ lunches. Until now, I hadn’t realised the importance of that.

Ministers also need to start communicating better with their non-ministerial colleagues and responding to requests for meetings and information more quickly and more positively.

Until recently I had not realised how lonely it can be to be a States Member, and no doubt others won’t have as well. But when you do see it, realise

it and appreciate it, then it does help to put many other things into perspective.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *