To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Every now and then a States Member lands on an issue that gets people engaged, and school fees is a good example
Share this:
Yet that’s the position that Deputy James Reed finds himself in this week.
Senator Ben Shenton’s proposal to freeze States support to fee-paying schools until after the end of a planned consultation on the future of the service, and Deputy Debbie De Sousa’s amendment extending the freeze to non-fee-paying schools, are likely to provide one of the key votes before the October elections.
And that’s not just because of the ideological point to be made about cuts generally, or the specific point about where they should fall, or even the point about fee-paying versus non-fee-paying schools. It’s because States Members recognise that one thing makes this subject more dangerous than most. And it’s this: people actually care about it.
There is a lot of nonsense spoken about which political issues actually arouse some interest and engagement from Islanders; one of the key ingredients of a States speech is an unconvincing assertion that one’s argument is backed by a massive but silent groundswell, often backed up with vague suggestions of support from unnamed constituents.
The truth is that by and large, people aren’t too bothered. And it’s worth noting that even for the issue of GST exemptions, the turn-out at public meetings was pretty poor.
But every now and then, some States Member lands on an issue that gets people engaged, and school fees is a good example. This week’s issue is somewhat complicated by the fact that Deputy Reed has managed to be on both the right and wrong sides of the debate.
His policy of cutting support to the fee-paying schools by £4.3 million over five years is the right one, if the alternative is cutting support to non-fee-paying schools. That’s just a fact.
The fee-paying schools are, as Senator Shenton says, the very model of what a public-private partnership should look like, but they are also a) subsidised and b) over-subscribed, and that simply makes no sense.
Given what we have learned this year (despite the objections of the minister and his department) about performance in some of the non-fee-paying schools, you’d think that it would be hard to argue that their funding should be cut. But that appears to be the alternative, given the minister’s commitment to maintaining university funding.
Deputy Reed, presumably, will argue that if both the proposition and Deputy De Sousa’s amendment are approved, he will have nowhere left to make the cuts from.
On the flip side, you could add that by the simple act of proposing these cuts in advance of the major consultation about the future of the education service, he has shown a pretty cavalier attitude to the significance of that consultation exercise.
It’s almost enough to make you feel sorry for him.
THE cutting and spending debate continues, with a senior UK MP, John Whittingdale, expressing shock and outrage at the dirty tactics used by … well, just
read on:
He said: ‘They have almost identified savings in areas and ways where they know that there will be considerable opposition. But there is wasteful spending and extravagant spending, and some salaries are too high. They have started talking about significant cuts … which they know are going to cause significant political protest.’
Gosh, the fiends. By a strange quirk of fate, he wasn’t actually talking about States departments, but about the BBC, which has threatened local news cuts to meet savings targets worth millions of pounds).
But he put it rather well, didn’t he?
IN the same week, the comments attached to the draft Civil Partnerships Law take the cynical approach to cutting and spending to a new low. The law predicts between 20 and 60 civil partnerships in Jersey once the provisions come into force.
So here was a golden opportunity for States departments to slip in some extra funding requests that only a Neanderthal could really vote against.
The cost of dealing with these 60 civil partnerships? Two new full-time staff in the court service and the Health department (the report was gloriously vague about whether it meant two in each, or two more in total), around £200,000 in one-off spending and a recurring £30,000 for the court service.
It’s almost as though they’re not taking this seriously.
ON the theme of things not being taken seriously by States departments, we shift seamlessly to the Code of Practice on Public Access to Official Information. The department has decided that ‘value for money’ reports on the schools cannot be disclosed because they contain information given to it by schools on condition of confidence. Put another way, the publicly owned body that administers publicly owned schools says that information about whether the schools are run efficiently is a secret. Go figure.
As luck would have it, one of these reports has come into our possession anyway. Its finding was that the children at the school in question (Les Quennevais) are keen to learn, that the staff do a fantastic job, that the atmosphere at the place is warm and encouraging – but that the school buildings aren’t fit for purpose.
And that’s what the Education department didn’t want you to know.
Related