Huge differences remain in national priorities and conflicting lobbies between suppliers and environmental interest groups. Each recognises the threat to the stability of current sources of Middle East oil and Russian gas, but further than that, there is little common ground over what could replace this dependency.

Now, at least, the UK has come up with an ambitious renewable energy strategy pegged to reducing carbon emissions by 50 per cent by 2020.

As fossil fuels are exhausted and the cost of extraction rises, along with their destructive environmental impact, there is obviously universal pressure to move away from traditional energy sources. The problem is, the alternatives continue to pose their own concerns.

While we in our own small Island confidently buy the overwhelming proportion of our electricity from France, we probably give scant consideration to the fact that 75 per cent of it is produced by nuclear power stations – albeit the most advanced in the world. And though not based in a seismically unstable area, France’s 58 plants share some of the vulnerabilities of Japan’s 53, if not the spectacular fate of the Fukushima installation.

Closest to us, and particularly symbolic, since its two existing reactors were commissioned in the mid-1980s, just as Chernobyl blew its top, is the expanding EDF complex at Flamanville. But look further south along the Cotentin peninsular, across the narrow stretch of sea from Mont Orgueil, and focus on the latest row of statuesque towers whose rotating blades now dominate the coastline.

Travel by train across the flat lands of Europe and you get the impression that they have sprung up across the landscape like giant asparagus spears. Unlike the Eiffel Tower, there’s little chance to watch them growing incrementally and to assimilate them into the environment. They arrive ready to assemble, go up in a matter of days and, like it or not, the march of the wind turbines is inexorable.

The contribution to the nation’s power appetite of these huge constructions, fast becoming a blot on everyone’s landscape, is hard to evaluate despite the huge amount of capital committed and the increasing amount of coastal waters now given over to their serried rows. Wind is certainly no respecter of demand, and the UK government wasn’t best pleased to have recently received a less than enthusiastic report by the respected John Muir Trust which concluded that they run below ten per cent efficiency for a third of operating time.

Perversely, they can work too well. Amid considerable embarrassment, it emerged recently that six Scottish farms had been paid a total of £300,000 to stop producing energy because the national grid could not absorb it. However, they are still a definite blip on French radar – and, it seems, the idea has caught on with our Guernsey cousins, not generally known for their innovative approach to environmental matters in respect of energy production or waste disposal. They have even installed a wind-testing station to evaluate the possibility of a leap into the renewable unknown.

There are now more than 280 wind-farms connected to the UK grid. As of 2010, they provided the UK with four per cent of its electricity. Somehow, the expectation that by 2020 wind will be producing 30 to 35 per cent of all domestic energy seems a tad optimistic.

Whatever the long-term benefits, there are undoubtedly short-term winners. Construction companies, mainly in Canada, Norway and Germany, are benefiting hugely from the rush to erect the blades, pylons and turbines, using a substantial amount of non-renewable energy in the process. Farmers, too, are latching on to substantial pay-outs for allowing the construction of turbines on their land.

On the other hand, we have heard concerns from environmentalists over the effects on wildlife, in particular flocks of migrating birds, a chorus of protest from NIMBYs fearing the despoiling of favourite countryside vistas, and the protest of those living near existing installations angered by the constant whine of the turbine blades.

However, you have to say that there is little general concerted opposition. It’s as though we’ve accepted the structures, like previous generations put up with the unsightly power grid-lines criss-crossing the countryside, regardless of the anxiety of pressure groups over their effects on the health of anyone living close-by.

It will be for future generations to evaluate whether the huge wind-farms being planted off the coasts of UK did, as many suggested, interfere seriously with the migration of fish stocks, confuse passing whales and cause a hazardous chicane for merchant shipping.

We have indeed become used to the sight of offshore oil-rigs on the horizon, while ancient windmills dominate many an artist’s canvas of the romanticised pastoral countryside. I suppose it’s mainly a question of scale. What may be great for the Ecréhous and isolated farmsteads in the Scottish highlands takes on a threatening unacceptability when grafted in gargantuan proportions in the Thames estuary.

The UK has also begun to invest in other alternatives – solar power, bio-digestible and recyclables. Wave-power is in its relative infancy, though the strong currents which have attracted engineers to the north coast of Scotland certainly exist around our own shores. Again, if the process can prove reliable and doesn’t shred seals or whatever else might be sucked into or deafened by the machinery, it is probably worth a try.

We know how to consume the ‘easy’ finite energy sources around us, but as the cost of extraction rises, political instability increases and the support for green initiatives gains momentum, there is no question that wind power will be charged with energising the air currents for many years to come.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *