To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Will David Cameron’s ‘Big Society’ be swiftly followed by our Terry’s ‘Small Society’?
Share this:
After all we tend to follow blindly what the UK does on most occasions.
There is certainly a need to motivate and inspire the electorate in Jersey as there is in the UK. All we’ve got is a cost-cutting government unable to project any vision of the future of the Island, other than that the public service will be a lot smaller.
This suits the rather limited aspirations of many taxpayers who just want to pay less tax. But it’s of little comfort to those who want Jersey to have the best possible public services, a thriving and diversified economy able to compete globally and an administration that thinks about more than just money.
Perhaps I’m being a little unfair because I know that many States members and even ministers have similar aspirations. They just have a funny way of showing it.
Take, for example, the Treasury Minister.
There’s no member of the States that works harder, is brighter or more focused. He just says some very silly things at times.
His latest quote in the JEP that a voluntary redundancy scheme in the States ‘will be particularly useful for slimming down management’ is a case in point.
Now I have a vested interest in the future of States managers (well, one at least) but even if I had just landed from Mars, I would find this a very strange thing for the Treasury Minister to say.
It presupposes that there is a need to slim down States management, but I’ve certainly never heard anyone with any credence claim that there are too many managers. In fact quite the reverse.
The Comptroller and Auditor General has consistently said that there are not enough managers in some States departments. The result of course, is that some departments have to spend a lot of money bringing in expensive outside consultants (from the UK, of course) just to do jobs that they should be doing themselves.
You would also expect that at a time when you’re trying to get more value for each pound spent, that you actually need more managers, but the Treasury Minister obviously doesn’t agree.
There is a certain amount of inconsistency here, however, because the minister certainly believes that the States needs more accountants and more ‘change’ managers. His department is about the only one in the States growing at present. Surely it can’t be a case of ‘Don’t do as I do…’
Perhaps what he meant to say was that we need to slim down some management, and indeed he has obviously identified the deciding factor in which managers should be allowed to go or which allowed to stay – how much do they cost. It’s not a question of whether they produce value for money or are doing a good job. It’s how much can be saved to put towards the target of £50m.
True, the Treasury Minister says that not all managers will be allowed to take redundancy. Morale is so low because of cost cutting and other factors that there probably wouldn’t be anyone left. No, some will have to stay.
The others who are surplus to requirements or perhaps simply no good, can go. But isn’t this a reflection on the States and senior management and the poor use of resources? Why do these posts still exist if the post holder is expendable? Or if the post holder is not up to scratch, why hasn’t he been retrained or replaced?
Part of the problem is therefore obviously poor management, so what do we propose to do? Cut more managers to make the job even more difficult. That proves that the focus is almost exclusively on saving money, not on doing what’s best for the future of public services.
So, if cost is the primary concern, perhaps we should start cutting at the top levels of management, where the pay is good by any measure, and then gradually work our way down until we’ve saved enough to meet the target. Silly idea? Not much more silly than the current redundancy lottery being instigated.
But what has this got to do with David Cameron’s Big Society? Well some cynics would suggest that his idea is simply a gimmick to hide the butchery he is undertaking in the UK’s public services.
I doubt whether something similar in Jersey would deflect the public’s attention away from the fact that their services are being cut or reduced. But it might give people some comfort to know that it’s all part of a bigger strategy and a vision to create a better island.
Reducing the size of the public sector may be part of it, but we should have the aim to end up with something that’s smaller, more efficient and better, and not just cheaper. So far, despite the rhetoric, all of the emphasis has been on cheaper.
We’re also too small to adopt Mr Cameron’s Big Society, so perhaps we should all aspire to achieving Terry’s Small Society.
We are indeed small enough to produce many of the results that the UK Government is trying to achieve with their bigger vision. However being small also means that it’s far more difficult to make the sweeping changes that Mr Cameron proposes in the UK.
Frankly, a trained monkey could save millions of pounds in the multi-layered UK bureaucracy. It’s much more difficult making savings in a small society where the loss of one or two jobs could mean a whole department being decimated.
Jersey, like all small islands, faces many challenges that bigger countries do not have. There is a particular skill or even an art in providing services in a community surrounded by water where you can’t just pop down the road for help.
Jersey’s public administration should already be world leaders in dealing with these challenges and should be able to demonstrate best practice and the ability to offer quality education, health and other vital services in a relatively isolated community.
If they can’t do that then we should be ashamed of ourselves because it’s either the result of poor management, lack of money or the absence of a vision in the States. Perhaps Terry’s Small Society could create that vision to counteract the current gloom.
Peter Body is editor of Business Brief magazine.
Related