To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Why anyone would want to live in a residential equivalent of La Moye prison is beyond me
Share this:
Two centuries later, a similar division exists because of the disparity between high-income earners in the private and public sector and the working class, coupled with planning and housing policies which favour high-density development concentrated in the town.
Nothing exemplifies this divide more than the plethora of mansion houses springing up in the countryside and ‘iconic grand designs’ near the coast.
That was until the ‘gated community’ arrived on our shores in Dandara’s luxury development above Portelet Bay and Belvedere, unveiled last week in an insert in this esteemed newspaper.
Gated developments or communities are fundamentally residential fortresses, designed to keep out those not welcome within its confines. And that that sends out a negative message. It could be argued that far from being a desirable location because of their supposed exclusivity, gated communities are no more than housing estates for snobs.
Depending on how much cash is left over from the mandatory services of a ‘leading’ British architect, the final touches to the ornate and often gilded gates are a flash CCTV system and floodlighting, ensuring that if the householder can’t see over the barrier fencing him or her in, then at least they have film footage of the outside world.
And should the property be set in extensive grounds, the entire estate is usually surrounded with high fencing, walls or impenetrable hedging.
I often wonder what measures are employed within these gated properties should the first line of defence be breached. A moat, perhaps, populated with piranhas?
Anti-personal mines dotted in the flowerbeds? Man-traps littering the lawn? Or are the grounds roamed after dark by a pack of ravenous hounds handled by ex-SAS security guards?
Apologies, dear reader, for getting carried away, but Jersey is in the main a safe environment in which to live and to raise a family compared with many locations in the UK. Most Islanders have no inclination to step over a stranger’s threshold uninvited, let alone walk into a courtyard or garden unless they have good reason, such as collecting for charity.
Nor was I aware that breaking and entering had become a national pastime.
Why anyone would want to live in a residential equivalent of La Moye prison is beyond me. Such extremes say more about the occupants’ insecurities than the perilous state of the society in which they live.
We all enjoy our privacy and admittedly, everyone’s home is their castle, but Jersey is no longer under threat from marauding brigands or enemy invasion – that’s why stockades went out of fashion and the Island’s governor stopped living in a heavily defended castle centuries ago.
Has the Island crime rate rocketed to such a degree that we are no longer safe in our own homes? Or is it the lack of specific legislation to deal with trespass that freaks out those new to our shores and who have moved from places where it is not safe to walk the streets during daylight let alone after dark?
Such imported insecurities could go some way to explain the growing fixation to be not only well and truly fenced in, but also alarmed and illuminated from dusk to dawn for good measure.
The marketing of Belvedere typifies the delusions of grandeur becoming prevalent in the high end of the Jersey property market. The ink of the Environment Minister’s signature on the approval to develop the old dairy site at Five Oaks was barely dry when the Island was comprehensively introduced to the concept of the gated community development.
Winchester-based architect Robert Adam’s designs have already impressed the man who introduced the idea of ‘iconic’ architecture to the Island – Senator Freddie Cohen. In approving the scheme, he described it as ‘absolutely fabulous’ with ‘the potential to be the best housing scheme in the Island’.
In reality, it is an upmarket estate of expensive quality homes beyond the reach of the majority of Island folk. Belvedere has not been designed to be a first step on the property ladder. It is more like a few rungs short of the top.
When Belvedere stands completed, it will have not only security gates like the development at Portelet, but also two gatehouses flanking the first line of defence against those who cannot afford to live inside.
On the positive side, Fortress Belvedere does attempt to respect the architectural vernacular of Jersey, and judging from the artist’s impressions in the marketing brochure, it is a vast improvement on recent estates as exampled by the ‘nondescript’ Jambart Lane development near St Clement’s Church. Although this blandness can be explained by the latter being a first-time-buyer development as opposed to an opulent one.
The only problem with attempts at respecting the vernacular is that once architects get a taste for peculiar styles and local idiosyncrasies, they have a tendency to go over the top. Take the case of Poundbury, the experimental new town on the outskirts of Dorchester in Dorset, and the brainchild of the Prince of Wales – a man not frightened of speaking his mind when it comes to modern architecture. Poundbury’s houses are in traditional styles, with period features such as bricked-up windows, as found on many old British buildings due to the window tax of the 18th and 19th century.
We already have modern homes built in a traditional style at Anne Port, with false chimneys for aesthetic affect, so how long before one of those brilliant UK architects charged to deliver top-class architecture starts designing houses with witches’ stepping stones and bricked-up windows?
How’s this for a unique selling point and the absolute must-have for pastiche granite developments: a bespoke granite lintel carved with the purchasers’ initials to emulate the traditional Jersey marriage stone?
What more could a developer give to yet another satisfied buyer?
Related