From Michael Green.

With reference to your report (JEP, 6 June) and with regard to the disturbing background information which Harcourt Developments appear to be embroiled in in the USA and which Deputy Gerard Baudains revealed in the States Chamber recently, it would appear in the light of the circumstances behind the efforts of Senators Walker, Cohen and Perchard to name but three who claim to be acting in the public interest, that there appears to be a good deal of political shenanigans of late over their enthusiasm for their support for Harcourt as their preferred developer which may eventually prove to be against the interests of the tax paying public of this Island.

Indeed Senator Walker has indicated that he was not aware of any lawsuits held against Harcourt until after the debate and he further indicated that ministers had done thorough checks on the company and then went on to claim that there is no legal dispute in Las Vegas despite the information offered by Deputy Baudains and subsequently reinforced by the serious allegations of the US Attorney for the plaintiff at Las Vegas being held against Harcourt and/or their associates.

Senator Perchard went as far as to say that the Las Vegas claims were false. Surely that is for the US court to decide. He further compounds his unfortunate remarks by appealing to States Members to ignore the ‘slight’ placed upon Harcourt by Deputy Baudains, thereby apparently attempting to impugn the Deputy’s reputation when he was merely presenting the facts as revealed by his tenacious research.

Furthermore, Deputy Baudains was clearly acting in the public interest in revealing the information which is more than could be said for those involved with the controversial Jersey land deal, the effects of which will be felt by all residents of this Island for years to come.

It would seem from the information provided by Deputy Baudains that the ministers failed in their obligation and duty of care to act in the public interest by clearly not carrying out thorough checks despite Senator Walker’s claim to the contrary and in particular they failed in their duty of care and obligation to heed the sound advice of a fellow States Member who clearly intended to protect the interests of the public by revealing the potentially unsavoury information of the Las Vegas lawsuit.

Further cause for concern appears to have surfaced as the result of Deputy Baudains’ concerns. For instance, Senator Walker suggests, without revealing its name, that a major bank would guarantee the deal. Surely that may depend on the outcome of the Las Vegas lawsuit which we are informed runs to $800m?

And we are also informed that if Harcourt reneges on its responsibilities WEB can step in to repossess the land and claim all of the guaranteed £95m or part thereof. I find this statement too simplistic and indeed quite naïve.

Does WEB really expect Harcourt to give up the land offered to them on a plate without a legal battle? Who will foot the expensive legal costs of such an action if Harcourt instigates legal proceedings? WEB or the general public? And what does WEB intend to do with the repossessed land if they did seize it bearing in mind this would amount to a huge partially completed construction site (if Harcourt pulls out for any reason) which to all intents and purposes will remain derelict whilst the envisaged lengthy legal battle is acted out as appears to be the case unfolding in the USA?

13 Bas du Mont,

Pier Road,

St Helier.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *