Stuart Moseley, of ITHSCI, explains why firms need to focus just as much on their old technology as on their new systems
WHEN businesses discuss digital transformation, the conversation usually centres on what comes next: artificial intelligence, cloud services, automation and increasingly powerful devices.
We spend much less time discussing what gets left behind.
That matters because one of the most overlooked data risks in a business may not be connected to its network at all. It could be an old laptop in a desk drawer, a collection of mobile phones in a storeroom or a retired server sitting in a cupboard.
The equipment may be switched off, but the information stored on it has not necessarily disappeared.
Workplace technology has changed enormously within a relatively short time. The telephone allowed people to communicate over long distances. Filing cabinets became computer databases. Dial-up connections gave way to broadband, cloud computing and mobile working. We have now reached a point where businesses can use artificial intelligence to process information at a speed and scale that would have been difficult to imagine a generation ago.
Each stage has brought genuine improvements. It has also created another generation of redundant equipment.
When a new laptop is issued, what happens to the old one? When a member of staff leaves, where does their phone go? When servers are replaced or an office closes, who checks every device and records what happened to it?
Too often, the answer is that the equipment is stored “for now”. Months become years and no one remains quite sure what is in the cupboard, who it belonged to or what information it contains.

Being disconnected does not make a device secure. Old hard drives and phones can retain customer records, employee information, emails, financial documents, passwords and commercially sensitive material. Deleting files or restoring a device to its factory settings may not be enough to make that information irretrievable.
This is why I believe digital transformation should be treated as a complete lifecycle rather than simply the purchase and installation of new technology. A project is not finished when the new system goes live. It finishes when the equipment being replaced has also been identified, assessed and dealt with securely.
That does not mean every redundant device must be destroyed. In many cases, reuse is the better option. Equipment that still works can be securely erased, tested and given a useful second life. This reduces waste, supports the circular economy and can allow a business to recover some value from assets it no longer needs.
Where information cannot be erased securely, or where a storage device is damaged, physical destruction may be the appropriate choice. The important point is that the decision should be deliberate, documented and suitable for the device and the sensitivity of the information involved.
The risk of a cyber-attack is now greater than ever, making this a good time for organisations to examine risks that are easy to miss. Cyber security is often associated with phishing emails, passwords, firewalls and online attacks. Those are important, but security also concerns the physical equipment on which business information is stored.
The Jersey Office of the Information Commissioner recently reinforced this point in its lessons from enforcement activity. It said organisations should have clear answers about both when personal information will be disposed of and how it will be disposed of securely. It also stressed that having a policy is not enough: organisations should be able to show that the process is being followed.
That distinction is important. A sentence in a data-protection policy will not help if nobody knows who is responsible for old equipment or where it has gone.
Businesses should be able to maintain an inventory of retired assets, record identifying details such as serial numbers and document whether the data was erased or physically destroyed. If an external provider is used, there should be clear responsibilities, appropriate oversight and an audit trail confirming how each asset was handled.
There are some straightforward questions every organisation can ask.
Do we know where all our redundant laptops, phones, drives and servers are? Who is responsible for them? Do we know what information they may contain? Is there a documented process for deciding whether equipment will be reused, recycled or destroyed? Can we provide evidence that the data was dealt with securely? Do staff know what to do when a device is no longer required?
If the answers are unclear, the first step does not need to be complicated. Start by opening the cupboard and creating an accurate inventory. Assign responsibility and agree a process that covers collection, storage, data erasure, destruction, reuse and reporting.
Technology will continue to move quickly. AI and whatever follows it will create extraordinary opportunities for Channel Islands businesses. But progress also requires us to take responsibility for the technology we leave behind.
The newest system may attract the attention but the oldest device may carry the greater risk.

