JERSEY lacks a “coherent” approach to developing and putting in place regulation that has resulted in potential gaps and duplication, according to a new report by the Comptroller and Auditor General.
Lynn Pamment described the Island’s current regulatory landscape as “complex and fragmented”, warning that it “does not allow for the delivery of value for money to be assured”.
However, the publication of her report comes just as Planning Minister Sir Mark Boleat unveiled an overarching policy to help ensure “a more consistent and co-ordinated approach” to developing regulation.
Ms Pamment’s audit sought to identify whether there are any overlaps or gaps in the design of regulation to effectively achieve public policy aims.
Among the key findings outlined in her report is that: “In many cases regulation has been reactive, created in isolation of other regulation.”
She continued: “This has resulted in ‘layering’ of regulations and potential areas of regulatory duplication.
“In comparison with other jurisdictions Jersey also has some areas where there are potential gaps in regulation.”
Ms Pamment concluded: “Jersey does not have a coherent approach to designing and implementing regulation.
“The landscape is complex and fragmented and does not allow for the delivery of value for money to be assured.”
The C&AG acknowledged that, at the time of her audit, the Island “had no established criteria or framework against which to make decisions about what to regulate and how”.
The government has stated that the new “Regulatory Principles Framework” unveiled by Senator Boleat yesterday is intended to ensure regulation is “evidence-based, proportionate and effective”.
It provides a shared reference point for officials and regulators when developing new requirements and reviewing existing arrangements.
This includes a number of tests to help policymakers determine if proposals are “necessary, proportionate and deliverable”.
Senator Boleat said: “Good regulation is essential to protecting the public, maintaining confidence and supporting Jersey’s prosperity.
“This framework will help ensure regulation is developed in a practical and proportionate way that reflects the needs of our Island.”
The minister argued that regulation should be based on “clear evidence” and a “proper understanding of risk”.
He continued: “By considering costs, benefits and alternative approaches at an early stage, we can maintain strong protections while avoiding unnecessary complexity and burden.
“A more consistent and coordinated approach to regulation will benefit Islanders, businesses and regulators alike, while respecting the independence of individual regulatory bodies.”

