A FATHER has been granted the legal right to make decisions in his daughter’s life after a judge found that his approach to vaccination was a “concern”, but “not a reason” to withhold parental responsibility.

In a recently published judgement, Judge Samantha McFadzean summarised evidence given by the mother of her child, referred to in court as Child 1, opposing her former partner’s application for parental responsibility.

The mother, the judgement states, opposed his application on the basis that it would block her ability to travel abroad with her daughter for purposes of the child’s further education.

She also referred in her evidence to ongoing disputes with the father of her child about vaccination, which she said was a reason for him not to be granted parental responsibility.

“She described disagreements about, for example, vaccination,” Judge McFadzean relayed.

“The court was concerned to hear evidence about her father’s approach to vaccination, particularly as it sounds as though he discussed vaccination directly with Child 1 in opportune terms which the court construed as damaging.”

While she noted that the court “respects the rights of parents to have differing views about such matters”, it was also accepted that the court “must be invited to make a decision” if the parents cannot come to an agreement.

The judge subsequently ruled that even a “fundamental disagreement” about vaccination “is not enough to withhold parental responsibility”, before clarifying that “differences of opinion should not be shared with a child” in the first place.

She added: “The father did not challenge the mother about her evidence in relation to vaccination, and the court observed that it would need to deal with an application or dispute in relation to immunization or vaccination as a separate matter.”

The father was granted parental responsibility for his daughter, subject to him swearing an affidavit obligating him not to disrupt the future travel arrangements of his daughter.