A SHORTFALL in planning and building income this year of around £2,000,000 has emerged due to a lack of large planning applications being submitted, a Scrutiny panel has heard.
Infrastructure and Environment chief officer Andy Scate revealed the figure during a hearing with the Environment, Housing and Infrastructure Panel yesterday.
Mr Scate said that, while there was still “a good number of planning applications coming in”, they were “of a smaller nature”, explaining that in 2025 and 2026 there had not been as many big submissions – which generate more fees – as would normally be seen.
He told the panel: “We’re about £2,000,000 short on planning and building income this year.”
Responding to questions from panel member Deputy Alex Curtis, Mr Scate noted that during periods of reduced income “the first expectation of the Treasurer is that we try and make the savings within the department and we hold jobs and things like that to try and balance that loss of income off”.
“We’ve done that as much as we can,” he continued.
“The reality is that when we get into this time of the year, when our year-end position is looking more fraught, so to speak, that’s where there’s another conversation with Treasury as to whether we will need some coverage from the central reserves.”
Later in the hearing, Mr Scate noted that the drop in income had only been seen this year and last year year, highlighting that “we do feel that it’s going to bounce back again”.
But he also said that, if it did not bounce back within the next three years, there would need to be “a conversation about a structural change to our income assumptions”.
“It’s too early to do that at the moment, because we can see the cause of the lack of income is the lack of big planning applications – and I can’t foresee a situation where the Island will not produce any big planning applications ever more.”
Mr Scate continued: “I think they will come back again as industry gets more confident and as some of the financial issues we’ve got around our development industry start to loosen, whether that be development finance or consumer finance.
“As that normalises and maybe eases, we would expect to see those applications come back on again.”
He pointed to pressures within the development industry including inflation on construction costs.
Planning and Regulation Minister Sir Mark Boleat said that, despite current staffing levels, statutory responsibilities were still being met.
“We’re prioritising,” he told the panel, though he acknowledged that “we’re not doing as much as we would like”.

