Longfield Villa Rue du Bocage, St Peter
Longfield Villa in Rue du Bocage, St Peter. Picture: DAVID FERGUSON

PLANS to demolish a care home and build 11 “assisted living” apartments have been unanimously approved by the Planning Committee.

States Members on the committee voted by five to zero in support of the application by the Apex Nursing Agency for the Longfield Villa home at Rue du Bocage in St Peter.

Case officer Chris Jones outlined the background to the application, which followed an earlier application for 14 apartments on the same side, which had been rejected as a result of concerns over parking, the loss of an established healthcare facility and the “overbearing” nature of the design.

Mr Jones said the new application had been improved in several respects, with three fewer units, more car parking spaces, a reduction in overall footprint and input from both the Health Department and private care providers about the existing home not meeting modern standards, even if it were to be refurbished.

“The applicant has addressed the concerns and produced a development that fits in the village environment and is respectful of neighbours,” he said.

One neighbour, Linda Walters, spoke to object to the application, which she said would be out-of-character and harmful to a small and beautiful village road. Mrs Walters said her privacy and that of a neighbouring house occupied by her daughter would be “totally gone” and that she was concerned about noise from first-floor balconies.

Speaking on behalf of the applicant, John Nicholson of MS Planning said Mrs Walters had “sensationalised” her concerns regarding the scheme.

“There was no appeal against the refusal of the previous scheme – the applicant went away, regrouped and has come back with a demonstrably better scheme that is in line with policy requirements,” he said.

Mr Nicholson said the government and private sector had confirmed they were not interested in using the site as a care home as it would not be possible to have sufficient rooms meeting modern standards, with the new scheme providing “assisted living” for Islanders aged 55 or over, with a manager based on site to provide “light care” as required.

Deputies Alex Curtis – the Planning Committee chair – and Tom Coles, alongside Constables Richard Honeycombe, Steve Pallett and Karen Stone, voted to support the planning officer’s recommendation to approve the application.