AN Islander who is completely blind in one eye waited almost a year for a follow-up appointment after surgery on their remaining functioning eye – during which time their sight significantly deteriorated.
The case has emerged in a recently published Social Security Medical Appeal Tribunal judgment concerning a dispute over the patient’s Long-Term Incapacity Allowance.
The Islander – identified only as “R” – underwent surgery on their left eye in Southampton in February 2025, having already lost all perception of light in their right eye.
They were subsequently seen at Jersey’s eye clinic in April 2025 and told to expect a further follow-up within four to six months.
However, according to evidence given to the tribunal, their next appointment did not take place until 25 February 2026 – around ten months after their previous assessment.
The patient said they received no follow-up in Southampton and had been advised that this should instead take place in Jersey.
By the time of the February appointment, tests appeared to show a significant deterioration in their left eye.
A doctor giving evidence on behalf of the Social Security Department said the February results were equivalent to a score of 6/36 on the Snellen scale, which is used to measure visual acuity.
If correct, the result would equate to an overall 80% loss-of-faculty assessment under the department’s guidelines – compared with the 45% assessment which was under appeal.
The doctor said deterioration of this magnitude could occur because a person relying on only one eye was vulnerable to further deterioration, but said it was unclear why such a significant change appeared to have occurred over a relatively short period.
They could not determine from the February test alone whether the deterioration was temporary or long-term and said further clinical information would be needed.
The judgment does not establish that the apparent deterioration was caused or worsened by the length of time between appointments.
The tribunal case itself centred on the patient’s incapacity assessment.
Before their operation, their combined loss of faculty had been assessed at 57%. Tests following surgery initially indicated that vision in their left eye had improved, resulting in the overall assessment eventually being reduced to 45%.
The patient told the tribunal they had not appealed in an attempt to receive more money, but because they wanted to understand why their assessment had fallen when they did not believe their eyesight had improved.
The tribunal dismissed the appeal, finding that the 45% assessment had been reasonable on the medical evidence available when it was made.
However, the panel said the subsequent February results “complicate matters” and that the patient’s overall visual acuity “appears to have deteriorated”.
It said steps should therefore be taken to establish whether the 45% assessment remained appropriate.
The tribunal granted permission for an early review relating to the patient’s left eye and said it was “highly desirable” that both claims should be reviewed early given the apparent deterioration between November and February.

