PLANS to extend the scope of Jersey’s Freedom of Information legislation to include arms-length organisations are finally being progressed – more than a decade after States Members agreed to it.

Assistant Chief Minister Malcolm Ferey said he felt that, while the move would involve “challenges”, it is “the right thing to do”.

It has been over ten years since the States committed to including ALOs – such as the Jersey Development Company, Ports of Jersey and Andium Homes – in the law’s remit following a proposition by Deputy Carolyn Labey in 2014.

However, implementing the proposition was delayed in 2015 and hit further problems in 2017 over what the government described at the time as “commercial issues” and, to date, the law has still not been extended.

Deputy Ferey said that he would be looking at how the change “would work in practice” following a review of the Island’s FOI legislation that included a public consultation towards the end of last year.

The assistant minister’s subsequent report cited “strong support” for including States-owned entities and statutory bodies within the scope of the law, “provided that implementation is phased and supported with adequate resources”.

It made a number of recommendations, including that consideration be given to including certain arm’s-length bodies under the law – which states that requirements can be prescribed for a scheduled public authority “to adopt and maintain a scheme requiring it to publish information”.

Deputy Ferey said: “My intention now is to take some of those recommendations forward, and see how bringing States-owned entities or arms-length organisations under the fold would work in practice.”

He continued: “I appreciate there are some challenges involved in doing that, but I think that the direction of travel will be to take a serious look at the timescale and the nature of organisations that can be brought within Freedom of Information.”

The update from Deputy Ferey comes shortly after Information Commissioner Paul Vane raised concerns about central government influence and interference in freedom-of-information decisions.

The commissioner stressed that decisions relating to requests made by individuals under the FOI law “must be dealt with by the appropriate scheduled public authorities and decisions must be made by them – and them alone”.

According to the government’s Central Information Governance Office, the purpose of the FOI legislation is “to support openness, accountability, and transparency across government by enabling the public to better understand and scrutinise government decisions and activities”.

Deputy Ferey added: “What we’ve just got to be mindful of is, we don’t want to impose high levels of bureaucracy. That always has to be balanced with the right to know.

“But for me, the right to know trumps most things in those circumstances.”

Deputy Ferey also noted that the public were “far more switched on to this than they used to be” and that any organisations brought under the law’s scope would need to be “ready and capable” of dealing with the volume of FoI requests that they might receive.

Deputy Karen Wilson, who chairs the Public Accounts Committee, said that there was always an “operational demand” associated with new legislation.

“Not just in relation to the Freedom of Information Law, but whenever we are designing laws going forward, we need to be thinking about what can be affordable as much as what the law is trying to address.”