From M M Keeping.

I WAS interested to read (JEP 18 May) that outline planning approval had been granted for the construction of 152 new homes on the ambulance station site at Rouge Bouillon.

My attention was drawn to the statement contained in your article that the plans will not go ahead until the Ambulance Service is rehoused at the current police station after, and I quote, ‘the States police has been moved to Green Street’.

Surely this should have read ‘if the States police are moved to Green Street’, because, correct me if I am wrong, the proposal to relocate the new police HQ at Green Street has yet to receive Planning approval, which at the very least places an element of uncertainty on the outcome.

This further leads me to question why the States have elected to spend thousands of pounds on architects’ fees, designing and submitting a housing scheme on a site that may not become available if the Green Street proposal fails to achieve planning approval.

The new police HQ has been open to public consultation for well over a year now, during which time architects have been instructed to proceed in undertaking the initial feasibility and design work on this new housing scheme under the assumption (nod and a wink) that the police will be relocated to Green Street.

This only reinforces the belief that I have had from the very beginning, that due to the political nature of the relocation of the police HQ and the pressures being brought to bear by the Treasury Minister, firstly on the police to accept this flawed proposal and, secondly, on the Planning department to approve it whatever the objections, made this a done deal from the outset and made a nonsense of the whole consultative process.

Much has been made of the fact that the resulting release of land from this venture would facilitate the provision of affordable housing. If all three services were to be moved to the Waterfront, the existing police site would also become available, thereby increasing the overall gain of housing units.

There is absolutely no doubt that this whole project is ill conceived, ethically bankrupt and cuts across the whole democratic process.

Hopefully, we have a strong enough Planning Minister to reject this scheme in the face of such political pressures. If so, I believe he can take comfort in knowing that there is not a single Islander who believes that Green Street is the right site for a police station and that the only people supporting it are those who are actively involved in promoting it.

I would, therefore, encourage him to ignore these pressures and do what is right and not what is easy and expedient.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *