To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
The ups and downs of being in or out of the EU
Share this:
All this was before our own constitutional whirlwind, namely the proposed re-designation of a few States Members and the early retirement of an egg-box full of others, and the success of his United Kingdom Independence Party in local government elections. ‘Stay with the UK’, said he. Well he would wouldn’t he, since UKIP advocates that Britain should thumb its nose at the EU. Perhaps unsurprising – given the general trends in UK politics – this is 100% opposite from his recommendation to us five years ago.
Whatever the advice, we are unquestionably in a bit of a bind. Back in March, we were told in no uncertain terms by Alistair Sutton, a seasoned advisor to the Crown Dependencies, that the UK has done very little on our behalf in defending the islands against the pride and prejudice of Brussels. Moreover, we are still smarting from the discriminatory putsch inflicted by George Osborne and a baying pack of acolytes over the LVCR issue. With friends like these, you could be forgiven for calling down a plague on both their houses when you consider the UK is charged with responsibility for our international affairs. The problem is – and remains, that we have only a very small voice on any global stage. We can sign up to all protocols, preen ourselves with official recognition of our transparency and compliance with international treaties, but it counts for little in the bear- garden of name-calling, competitive self-interest and inappropriate remarks by local politicians even given the vagaries of mis-translation.
To be honest, we probably start from a position of self-inflicted disadvantage. With hindsight, our robust expectations of riding an independent wave back in 1971 when our relationship with the UK and Europe was determined, may have come back to haunt us. When things go wrong for the big boys, they inevitably turn on the minnows, particularly if they believe we’ve outmanoeuvred them. The opportunities open to our finance sector have undoubtedly caused resentment: LVCR, which was designed as a small-scale local concession but then hijacked and exploited by corporate predators, including many from the UK, was cracked by the Osborne Treasury hammer at a time when convenient scapegoats were being herded to sacrifice on the political altar of financial incompetence and envy.
Pricked by the electoral success of Mr. Farage’s supporters, the UK Tories are rubbing fresh salt into the running sore that’s gnawed at them from the day Edward Heath learnt French – namely Europe. Two former Conservative Chancellors of the Exchequer, Nigel Lawson and Norman Lamont are advocating the UK pulls out of the EU – and this are where it all becomes a bit rich – because they feel the big boys in Europe are trying to over-regulate and cut down the UK’s financial services industry. Well, we know how that feels, don’t we. Yet for the same reasons we could not cut ourselves adrift from Westminster, the prospect of the UK, including a wobbly Scotland, turning its back on Brussels would be equally hazardous. The Prime Minister knows it, but he’s also aware that the public – and a large section of his quarter-backs, are not generally on his side. It is, of course macho and crowd-pleasing to advocate going it alone, but the gap between two stools is cavernous. We are already feeling anxieties surfacing. Indeed David Cameron was at pains to tell a meeting of global investors last week that Britain needed to fight the proposed EU tax on financial transactions because the City of London is the finance centre for the world and any such measures would be uniquely discriminatory. Scale it down and look at us: – sneezes in Canary Wharf cause colds on our Waterfront. It means in effect that we remain tied ever closer to our friends from the north than those on the Continent. Moreover, there’s a hint of a more ‘grown up’ approach to our Bailiwicks from Westminster, if the music filtering out of the Justice Committee reviewing Whitehall’s formal links with our laws and relationships is to be believed.
It might be an anathema to those for whom the coast of Jersey represents the edge of the world, but given our ceremonial homage to the union flag last week, and the outcome of a referendum that endorsed the role of Constables representing the interests of their individual parishes in the States, the prospect of one Channel Islands MP – or two – at Westminster might carry more sway when it comes to issues directly affecting our livelihood than the current dilemma of merely standing outside peering in. How differently might the LVCR debacle have been resolved if our representative sitting in their House held a vote which was crucial to a shaky government majority?
It all depends, of course, on trust and understanding, and we are right to be wary. But we are already subject to European conventions and the jurisdiction of the Privy Council, so arguably, we would be surrendering less than we could gain. Freed from delusions of international grandstanding, our local legislators could concentrate more comfortably on what makes the Island tick. The time is fast approaching when we should be examining our cap size and calculating whether it should hang on a British hook or a European one. All we have to do is make the choice. Now there’s the scope for a real referendum.
Related