To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Battle of Flowers community spirit needed in States reform
Share this:
However it’s not just a colourful parade of floral masterpieces. It’s still very much a community event, where Islanders come together willingly and for no monetary reward to create one of the biggest carnivals of its type in Europe. It’s simply Jersey at its best.
There is an obvious conflict between those who want the Battle to become a more professionally managed event capable of attracting more tourists to the Island, and those who are happy to see it simply as a communal effort by the same people getting together year after year.
Changes will undoubtedly come, but hopefully the Battle spirit will remain the same.
It may be stretching it a bit to claim that the Battle of Flowers proves that our island community can work together in harmony for the common good. Certainly the enormous fuss about the pointless referendum on electoral reform tends to show otherwise.
I have tried to steer away from any involvement in the ludicrous arguments about options A, B or C in the recent referendum. There’s nothing I can say that will persuade some people to change their minds. They are now firm supporters of one option or the other, and will fight bitterly for it.
The argument has even progressed from simply an academic choice between one proposal for reforming the States and another. Personalities are now very much involved, and so who supports what has become just as important as what ‘what’ is.
Some good could come out of this debacle because it might be seen as a defining moment in Jersey’s political history. There are clear divisions emerging which could be used as the basis for a party political system, which is what the Island really needs. It won’t happen, of course, because there’s still the pervading myth that the Island should be governed by 50 or so independently-minded individuals who don’t follow any political dogma (well at least not in public). So we’re stuck with this mess.
However, despite my reluctance to get involved with the futile arguments about option A, B or C, there are a couple of very important factors to consider.
The first is that the referendum should not have been held in the first place. The Island is not very familiar with the concept of a referendum, which therefore needs to be used very sparingly. Certainly most people won’t be keen to rush into another one.
But the reason the referendum should never have taken place, is because it was painfully obvious that the electoral commission had failed miserably to define questions that gave the electorate a real choice.
There was a choice between A or B, of course, but the results would indicate that this wasn’t enough for a large proportion of the electorate who didn’t want either A or B. So they either didn’t vote, or they voted for the status quo in the mistaken belief that it was their duty to vote even if they didn’t agree with what they were voting for.
Pushing forward with a referendum on this basis was a grave mistake that has severely damaged the reputation of States members, the majority of whom felt that they were forced to ignore the referendum. But no one said that the referendum was binding, and indeed we were warned it was not binding, so those critics who harp on about their views being ignored, haven’t got a leg to stand on.
So we are effectively back at square one, not because the States ignored the referendum result but because the referendum was flawed and should never have happened. The electoral commission pushed ahead with it in the hope that it would result in some progress in this intractable problem which has tied up the States for years. Unfortunately it didn’t, so now we can forget the referendum and options A, B or C.
But how do we now make progress in reforming the States? Perhaps the answer is to go back to basics, take the problem in bite-sized chunks and ask ourselves what any reform is meant to achieve.
I for one, doubted that any of the recent referendum options would have produced an increased interest by the public in States affairs or in voting. Most members of the public couldn’t care a fig about whether the States includes Constables or not. All they want is to have a choice at election time of candidates with clear policies who have some chance of getting them implemented. None of the reform proposals helped in that respect.
Also there certainly shouldn’t be any argument about whether a vote in town is less valuable than a vote in St Mary. This simply isn’t a part of the reform process, because votes should be equal whatever kind of States we have.
Sorting that out would get rid of one question that has muddied the process. Electoral boundaries should either be redrawn or the number of representatives adjusted to ensure voter equality. This is not reform; it’s simply a requirement of democracy.
Then we could get rid of another annoying distraction by grasping the nettle and deciding whether the Constables should remain in the States or not. This seems to be the issue that is holding up any other kind of reform and needs to be decided separately. This will mean settling the argument about whether the parishes need this separate representation in the States, but it’s still a relatively simple question. The States must make this decision before going on to further reforms, although it could also be put in a clearly-worded referendum – and I’m not joking. That referendum would at least produce a clear result.
Having agreed the size of constituencies and the presence or otherwise of the Constables, the States would then be free to concentrate on real reform which produces a wider choice of election candidates (yes, more candidates, not less) and helps those elected to do their job properly. Indeed there’s probably a greater need to help States members become more effective than there is to decide how many of them there should be, but so far we have been distracted from the real issues.
The distraction with numbers has proved to be the downfall of the current reform process because the number of political representatives is largely irrelevant. It’s now time to ignore the numbers and concentrate on quality.
Related