Now, I have no intention of launching into the details of the personal grief that was spilled over the employment tribunal’s table, other than to rue the amount of licence payers’ money that has been wasted over this rancorous little saga.

At the same time I confess to feeling pretty fed up with the obvious rash of mischievous glee with which sections of the press latched on to the case, turning the plaintiff into a persecuted heroine because she made herself readily accessible and provided them with a hapless proxy Joan of Arc with which to indulge in some ritual ‘Beeb bashing’.

TV viewers deserve the best, most appropriate talent displayed before them. The popular conceit is that this is a responsibility entrusted to the competence of programme producers to achieve that from their teams. If you learn anything in broadcasting, it is that technology advances fast, audience interest constantly changes, and production methods and individuals must adapt as rapidly as the medium itself.

So when any element can no longer ‘hack it’ there comes the inevitable time for replacement. That has little to do with age or gender and even less with the intervention of a heavy-handed grievance procedure which brings no credit to either party.

As with the case of Miriam O’Reilly, displaced from the refreshed and re-scheduled ‘Countryfile’ programme on BBC1, it only serves to reopen the floodgates of special pleading by superannuated camera dollies – both male and female – who believe that once the lens has grown accustomed to their face, it embalms them with an inalienable right to permanent flattery in the nation’s hearts and front rooms.

Like politics, the media – particularly television – attracts those who revel in the public limelight. Wrongly, in many cases, they attribute their longevity in the public eye as representing universal approval and adulation. Sadly, it’s often more a question of convenience and familiarity. However, the longer they remain, the more entrenched they become, wallowing in an institutionalised status and displaying imperious resentment of any pretenders who should appear in the wings.

Deputies, Senators, who’ve passed their sell-by dates show themselves reluctant to stand down. African presidents take it further and cling on even if the popular vote has gone against them. So you’re left with a moribund continuum and a list of faces which do keep ‘popping up’ regularly – for a time, though this normally has less to do with talent than with the power of a pushy agent, and their appearances dwindle when their backers tire of them or their demands become unreasonable. At least there’s always the lure of a ‘gong’ to round off a glittering career – though, that can be spectacularly misunderstood as an endorsement to carry on.

So the aftermath of last week’s tribunal ruling has provided the predictable orgy of newspaper comment hailing the ‘humbling of the BBC’ by titles known for packing their own pages with images of elderly, sober, well-behaved citizens, I don’t think!

The hypocrisy is further compounded by their claim to strike a blow for the disadvantaged by producing lists of older female broadcasters whom they have the nerve to identify as victims of age or sexism. How insulting must it be for the likes of Angela Rippon, Gloria Hunniford, Jenny Bond to learn that they are on the ‘past-it’ list when their own ‘Rip-off Britain’ programmes are topping the TV ratings?

Or for those who might benefit from a campaign to force the broadcasting organisations to employ a quota of these so-called ‘cougars’.

The point is, surely, that talent will out. Who can forget the drubbing handed out to the BBC’s own Director General by P.D. James when, at 90 years of age, she edited the Today Programme on Radio 4? You’d also have to go far to hear a more consistently lucid and accomplished broadcaster than 78 year-old Dame Joan Bakewell who is at home both on radio and television.

There’s no question that experience is a valued ingredient of public life. It comes with longevity and underpins probably half the seats in the States and a large proportion of the House of Lords, which stands out as probably the most densely packed chamber of excellence I have ever had the privilege to witness in action. But the cause for valuing experience and personality on the box has not been helped by a string of high-profile complainants bearing grudges.

Sadly, the O’Reilly case only serves to highlight how an individual, who after twenty years in the same cosy nature-lifestyle show, can lose touch with the passage of reality, and despite the triumphal rhetoric, set back the general advancement of those in a role where appearance, affability and adaptability are part of the job spec. A reputation for litigiousness and vanity is, to say the least, counter-productive.

Clearly there will be ramifications. It is possible that stricter rules will be introduced to prevent individuals ‘bedding in’ to comfy slots. As a result, the role of the presenter might even become more precarious. It is definitely right that any public body that receives public funding should be subject to scrutiny over fair employment practices, though it is unrealistic for clunky prescriptive bodies, however well-intentioned, to dictate the professional rule book.

To perform and present will always carry an element of risk and short-termism.

That’s show business.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *