From Keith Flemington.

I WAS fortunate to see a copy of your issue dated 19 July 2008.

I was for over 20 years privileged to conduct sales by auction in the Island and I am personally saddened by the decision of the States to end the ban on the importation of semen into the Island.

I found over the years that the biggest selling point at auctions was the purity of the breed. The ‘Jersey Jersey’ pure for more than 200 years will now be lost.

While I accept that the yields may not have equalled those of Jerseys around the world, and that there is need to look to the future, I was surprised by the size of the majority in favour of lifting the ban.

I was privileged to attend the recent World Conference and saw many classes of young and senior cows with the confirmation that would be hard to find anywhere in the world.

I am amazed that the new rules not only allow the importation of semen from Jersey bulls, but also of other breeds to produce beef crosses, which may improve the profitability for the ever-decreasing numbers of milk producers.

In my experience of over 40 years as an auctioneer and valuer of all breeds, with it will come many problems, including calving difficulties if cows are put in calf to breeds such as Belgian Blues or Charolais.

The argument was put that Guernsey had been importing semen without any significant problems since 1996. Some years ago I visited Guernsey to see the animals paraded at their major show and I was horrified at the low standard of type and confirmation, particularly of animals served by Canadian Guernseys. There are very few Guernsey herds left on the mainland and very few classes at any of the major shows.

I am sure some of your readers will consider that this letter is the ramblings of a silly old man, and you may well be right!

I was privileged to put my hammer down on the last cow I sold by auction at a dispersal sale (of Bruton Knowles, Gloucester) in the Island during the last foot-and-mouth outbreak, where bids were received from the mainland over the telephone from breeders who could not see the animals that they were buying, because they were not allowed in the Island.

They were confident enough that the animals they were buying would be of the usual high standard, having taken advice of well-respected Island breeders. The result was a fantastic sale, with many four figure prices.

I believe you are selling the ‘family silver’, but I wish all the producers good luck in the future and I hope prosperity and profitability will rise.

Pear Tree House,

Regent Street,

Stonehouse,

Gloucestershire.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *