It has been ten years since Guernsey last won the Siam Cup but in front of a 4,000-strong crowd at St Peter on Saturday the visitors clawed their way back from being 24-9 down to win 28-24, the final score coming from man of the match, T E (Tom) Smit, who darted beneath the posts in the 74th minute.
In an epic encounter, described by international referee Donal Courtney as a ‘game of great intensity, a mixture of passion and control’ Jersey were three scores ahead of Guernsey 50 minutes into the match.
However, ten minutes having been played in the second half and Jersey marginally on top, second row player Roger Quirk was red-carded and the game, already on a knife-edge, was about to change.
At the time Guernsey had been camped in the Jersey 22 for three or four minutes, but most of the crowd couldn’t understand what had happened.
Why were Jersey suddenly a player down with 30 minutes to go? ‘There had been periods of bad feeling, which you’d expect in a game like this.
Then this player ran from 20 yards out and boxed a Guernsey player directly under my nose,’ said referee Courtney, who later also sin-binned Steve O’Brien, for kicking the ball away from an offside position.
With only seven pack players on the field Jersey should have struggled, but it was during this period that the home side actually moved the score up to 24-9 when winger Matt Davenport-Brown made the most of continual pressure to touch down on the right, following good interplay by the threes.
Two minutes after that try, in the 55th minute, O’Brien was shown the yellow card and although Jersey had a three-try cushion, it soon became two scores, then one, and finally nothing.
Yet, ironically, Jersey were at times the better side, even when reduced to 14 men.
‘For too much of the game we couldn’t get the ball to the wingers,’ said Jersey coach Dai Burton afterwards.
‘We were over-elaborate in midfield.
‘Losing Roger (Quirk) was a major blow.
But even when we were reduced to 13 men, I felt we could score.
Having said that, take nothing away from Guernsey.
They were aggressive and defended well.
We paid for our naivety.’ After a hesitant opening ten minutes Jersey went in front with a Darren Toudic penalty from wide on the right.
Three minutes later Guernsey’s stand-off Smit levelled the scores and with the exception of one great Richard Finch run, which ended when he was brought down by Guernsey captain Carl Johnson, the visitors were in the ascendancy, mainly because of booming kicks to the left or right of full-back Gareth Jeffreys.
However, ten minutes before half-time Davenport-Brown took the ball from a maul ten yards out and ran, crab-like, right, towards the Guernsey try line.
Two yards short the ball was popped up to flanker Brett Els who touched down.
Toudic converted.
Four minutes later another Smit penalty made it 10-6 but despite a great deal of possession, Guernsey never looked like scoring tries.
The same was true for the first ten minutes of the second half, when Jersey extended their lead after hooker Doc Snook, wide out on the wing, took the ball from a long Dave Miles’ pass to burrow over.
A superb Toudic kick made the score 17-6 and Jersey seemed to be coasting.
However, a moment’s lack of discipline by Quirk, when he hit out at Guernsey No 6 Matt Morgan, changed the whole pattern of the game and arguably the result, before the score went to 17-9 following Smit’s ensuing penalty.
Even Davenport-Brown’s try, when he avoided two would-be tacklers to dot down to the left of the posts from a Jeffreys’ pass, a try converted again by Toudic, wasn’t enough to stop the rot.
For in the 55th minute relentless Guernsey forward pressure saw the imperious Carl Johnson shrug off a half-tackle to score.
Scrum-half Willoughby Bloem converted and it was 24-16.
Smit himself nearly scored a few minutes later, running fully 50 yards before being scragged near the line.
That run, however, had served its purpose.
With no protection from a depleted back row from the ensuing set scrum Jersey scrum-half Dave Miles fumbled the ball and his opposite number, Bloem, crashed over.
The scoreline was now 24-21.
Jersey were rattled, and the only noise from the crowd was a raucous ‘Guernsey, Guernsey’ from 50 or so supporters on the northern touchline.
It was 4.20 pm.
Still time for either side to score but Jersey were on the back foot and making the most basic of errors.
In the 76th minute they paid for their mistakes.
Smit took the ball at outside half, was half-checked by Mark White but then straightened, and with no last line of defence strolled through for the winning try.
After taking the kick himself, the score was 28-24 to the visitors and although Jersey tried to raise their game for a final onslaught, they had neither the guile nor the energy to do so.
Having scored 16 points out of 28, Smit was arguably Guernsey’s player of the match, but for captain Carl Johnson, the reason for his side’s first win in ten years was: ‘discipline.
We kept it even when we were losing.
We knew we were playing well and in the end we didn’t sneak the win.
We won fair and square.
I’ve never experienced anything like this; to a Guernseyman it’s the equivalent of winning the World Cup.’ Jersey: Jeffreys, Finch, White (Banahan), Whelan, Davenport-Brown, Toudic, Miles, Nobes, Snook, Chamier, Quirk, McAlister (captain), Els, O’Brien, Henderson.
Guernsey: Elliott, Livesey, Johnson, Johnston, Ferbrache, Smit, Bloem, Thomas, Thomas, Mroch (Nicolle), Flynn, Thompson, Morgan, Jones (Willis), Regnard.

