On Wednesday Assistant Health Minister Hugh Raymond said the last-minute call for people to name locations was nothing more than a ‘paper job’, adding that ministers ‘need to be seen to reconsider the sites’.
And today fellow Assistant Health Minister Steve Pallett said the move would lead to ‘unrealistic sites being put forward’, send the project ‘down a cul-de-sac’ and could lead to a ‘delay’ in the scheme.
The consultation, which is due to run for six weeks, is inviting Islanders to put forward their own site suggestions for the £466 million project – ten months after a decision to build on the existing Gloucester Street site was rescinded.
Assistant Health Minister Steve Pallett has said he ‘doesn’t see the point’ of the consultation and that it risks adding further delays to the already beleaguered project.
‘My personal view is that there have been 40-plus sites identified and they have all been reviewed, and opening it up to public suggestions is just going to lead to unrealistic sites being put forward,’ he said.
‘This is not going to help. They have identified sites and all this will do, I believe, is delay the process and I don’t see the point of it at all.
‘This isn’t an issue to go to the public. There are other issues that need to go to the public like the Jersey Care Model has.
‘This, I believe, is just going down a cul-de-sac.’
Yesterday, Senator Pallett’s fellow Assistant Health Minister, Deputy Hugh Raymond, said ministers ‘had to be seen’ to be reviewing all available sites but that he hoped a shortlist of four or five potential sites would be identified and revealed next month.
But just hours after Deputy Raymond spoke to the JEP, a government press release announced that the original longlist of 41 sites would be reviewed, with public suggestions added to the list. The press release included comments attributed to Deputy Raymond.
An initial 2012 survey of 41 possible options was drawn up, with many of them deemed unsuitable for a hospital. Five sites were eventually identified – Overdale, the Waterfront, Warwick Farm, St Saviour’s Hospital and the existing Gloucester Street site. The People’s Park was ruled out of consideration following a proposition from St Helier Constable Simon Crowcroft, although several Members admitted that the park was probably the best option.
Senator Pallett added: ‘I would say obvious sites would be Warwick Farm and Overdale. The Waterfront should be considered, although I don’t think it should go there.
‘I also think People’s Park should be looked at again, despite what happened last time. There will be third-party objections but it needs to be looked at.
‘This isn’t going to help. It is risking a delay and things need to happen on this, as the clock is ticking.’
A preferred site is set to be named in September 2020. More than £40 million was spent on the project before the States approval of Gloucester Street was overturned – at least £27 million of which had to be written off. And the more recent Our Hospital project has so far cost £189,000.
In response to Senator Pallet, Assistant Health Minister Hugh Raymond said: ‘The previous hospital project did a lot of technical assessments on the 41 sites that they considered, and the information that was gathered is still valid. Therefore, the Our Hospital project does not need to commission new research for those sites, because it can assess them against the new criteria using the existing technical information.
‘This will save money by not commissioning unnecessary additional research, and means that we can run a paper exercise to assess those 41 sites, rather than conducting new research.
‘We expect the longlist of sites to be narrowed down to a small shortlist early in 2020, and the shortlist to be narrowed down to a preferred site by September, after more detailed assessments.’

