By Mike Beaugeard
HAVE you ever found yourself walking, cycling or motoring around some of the most beautiful, secluded parts of our Island and wondered: how on earth did they manage to get planning permission to build there? No doubt a great many of you immediately conjured up a mental image of the proverbial large brown envelope, bulging with wodges of the folding stuff. The truth, though a great deal less sinister, is no more palatable.
The evolution of formal planning regulations in Jersey took place relatively recently. For example, we did not have a properly-constituted Island Plan until 1962, backed up by the Island Planning Law in 1964. Until then, the story of planning and development on our tiny rock was a tale of intrigue, deception, broken promises, catastrophic incompetence, unfettered greed and political chicanery on a sometimes grand scale. Sadly, the evidence might tend to suggest that nothing much has changed in the intervening years.
It is simply not possible to do ample justice to such a complex subject in a short article such as this, so I heartily recommend that those who wish to gain a greater insight into how we allowed some of the more questionable property developments dotted around our countryside and coastal areas delve into The History of Planning in Jersey, published by the late Bernard Morris in 2016. I should perhaps warn you in advance that those of a cynical nature may well find more fuel to add to the flames of indignation which burn brightly whenever the subject of politicians and property development are discussed.
Much of what occurred in the Island before 1964 from a planning point of view is veiled in secrecy, partly because many of the minutes of committee meetings before then were subject to a 100-year embargo and, because, unlike in the UK, members of the public were not legally entitled to attend such meetings.
Indeed, I’ve just discovered details of a proposition lodged by Senator Stuart Syvret as recently as 1999 precisely to allow such public attendance – something which had previously been anathema to the majority of our politicians.
But I digress. The pre-war decades of the 1920s and 30s saw a significant boom in development, particularly along coastal areas to the east and west fed by the light railway system. The greater use of cars also saw increasing urbanisation in the countryside.
At this time there were no significant controls in place to prevent any inappropriate development. However, an attempt was made in 1932 to introduce a law to protect the Island’s natural beauty.
Consisting of six broad principles, it is the first of these which most interests those of us worried about conservation in Jersey. It expressly ‘forbade the building of houses or buildings in the bays or on the cliffs and coasts of the island, or in a controlled zone’.
Yes, indeed, whatever happened to that good intention, you may well be wondering. ‘Nothing’ is the answer, because, as with many of the subsequent attempts to control development, these early principles were far too woolly, undefined and full of loopholes to adequately protect those parts of our island which most needed them. After the Germans came and went, some of our politicians decided it would be a jolly good idea to redevelop many of their gun emplacement and bunker sites because – surprise, surprise – these locations featured some of the most stunning vistas across our most-beautiful bays.
By this time – the 50s, 60s and 70s – we were already allowing inappropriate developments in areas of natural beauty such as the sand dunes of St Ouen’s Bay. Witness the now sprawling estate at Mont à la Brune: originally intended as 12 small houses, it now overspills into the dunes themselves.
Another totally inappropriate development was the Pontins Holiday Camp which, although it existed in different form before the war, should never have been built on the Plémont headland in the first place.
It was not until 2015 that, after tremendous lobbying by the National Trust for Jersey and some of our more enlightened politicians, the site was finally returned to nature.
There are far too many examples of bad planning decisions, many in apparent disregard to the formal Island Plans subsequent to the first in 1962. Those from 1986, 2001 and 2011 were also supposed to protect our coastal and countryside areas of outstanding beauty from unnecessary development.
One can only guess at the motivations of politicians and civil servants who failed to safeguard the interests of those Jersey folk who put a love for their Island home above the pursuit of profit or self-interest.
I have said this many times and will continue to say it ad infinitum: Jersey’s greatest asset is the natural beauty of its coastline and countryside. If we continue to allow inappropriate development and encroachment into what is effectively our communal back garden, then all the money in the world will not compensate for the loss to our mental and physical wellbeing. Is a single one of our politicians prepared to champion that cause above all else?
-
As a young man, Mike Beaugeard served in the Army. He has also been a musician, hi-fi business owner, Conservative local politician, property manager, and security officer. Now retired, he is a keen amateur photographer. He describes himself as a staunch advocate of the Plain English Campaign.

