THE Health Minister has pledged to use a damning governance review of the General Hospital as ‘a watershed moment’ to get to grips with a catalogue of issues which could be putting patient safety at risk.
An independent report conducted by Professor Hugo Mascie-Taylor – who has completed major health reviews in the UK – revealed a series of concerns with management and the working culture within the Hospital.
While conducting interviews during seven visits to the Island last year, staff told him:
– Some sick patients were not properly monitored.
– Middle-grade doctors sometimes worked potentially unsafe hours.
– Middle-grade locum doctors, whose competence was not known when they arrived, were often not properly supervised.
-There were too few physicians to care for acutely ill patients.
– Some clinicians failed to complete mandatory training.
– The results of radiography tests were sometimes not signed off or even seen.
And the professor concluded that poor governance meant it was impossible to establish the quality and safety of care within the General Hospital. He also found some staff reluctant to report shortcomings either because they doubted anything would be done or feared reprisals.
Responding to the report, Health Minister Karen Wilson said: ‘I can’t argue with what Professor Mascie-Taylor has found. This is the account that staff have provided him with in relation to the clinical practice that is there at this moment in time.
‘The thing I want to make sure is that people don’t get frightened because of the report because I think it’s important to recognise that there are thousands of people who go through the door every year that have really good clinical outcomes,’ she said, although she accepted that she was not yet in a position to give an absolute assurance over safety concerns raised in the report.
Asked whether medical professionals were still working long hours that could pose a threat to patient safety, the minister replied: ‘What I have asked the medical director and the director-general and the chief executive of the public service to do is to give me those assurances; and what I think will be strengthened in that regard is the expectation that there will be a properly organised accountability framework that addresses some of these issues associated with medical deployment and other professional deployment.’
The minister praised Health and Community Services director-general Caroline Landon – and staff who participated in the review – for their bravery in raising the issues and she added that her expectation was that the Hospital administration would now turn things around.
‘We are talking about historical issues here that have been part of a culture that has been identified with the Jersey health system and I think we have to give people an opportunity right across the board to make a contribution to turn this around,’ she said.
Deputy Wilson was meeting health staff yesterday afternoon to set out her initial response to the report, which includes the appointment of a ‘freedom-to-speakup champion’, an independent person to whom staff can safely report matters of concern.
Meanwhile, the Jersey Care Commission announced that it was likely that there would be a law change to allow it to extend its independent inspection of care facilities to include hospital services.
The JCC will also participate in the running of an independent survey next month of Islanders who have received hospital care to establish what they described as ‘an additional insight into the quality of care experienced from a user’s perspective’.
Deputy Wilson said she wanted to move away from a blame culture with the service and to develop better engagement with the public so they could see that the department was working hard to deliver good-quality safe care.
She said she did not give any credence to suggestions that the problems were attributable to ‘the Jersey Way’, an expression used by a number of those who spoke to Professor Mascie-Taylor.

