A senior police official has spoken out against officers facing “trial by social media” after a car carrying Labour MP Dawn Butler was stopped on Sunday.
Ms Butler, who is black, accused police of racial profiling after the BMW in which she was travelling was pulled over in Hackney, east London. The car was driven by a friend, who is also black.
However, Metropolitan Police deputy commissioner Sir Steve House has defended the officers’ conduct after reviewing the incident, footage of which – filmed by Ms Butler – has spread widely on social media.
Sir Steve said the officers had acted properly, and it was “unfair” that police should have their actions hastily posted and scrutinised on social media, rather than being reviewed through proper channels.
“Officers expect to be scrutinised and there are existing, appropriate and proportionate processes for making complaints and for facts to be established, and on the occasions where there is fault – unlike this case – for consequences to follow.
“The increasingly routine trial by social media is unfair and damaging to individual officers and has the potential to undermine the role our communities need us to do to protect them and keep them safe from violence.”
Sir Steve said he had discussed with Ms Butler her concerns over why the stop was made, adding she had no complaint about how it was conducted.
He said the officers were from the Violent Crime Task Force and were in the area “as part of our proactive work to protect communities from violence”.
“The officers ran a number plate check on the vehicle. At this stage, the officers still didn’t know who the occupants of the car were, including their ethnicity because the car windows were tinted.”
A mistake was made, however, when an officer incorrectly entered the car’s registration into his computer, Sir Steve said, adding that was when the Police National Computer returned details of a car from another region of the UK.
As a result, he said, the officers had decided to conduct further checks by stopping the vehicle and engaging with its occupants.
“I expect officers to have professional curiosity and I would have done the same,” he said.
Having viewed video footage Sir Steve said the officers “acted professionally and politely, explaining why the stop was made and, when realising there was a mistake, explaining this and continuing to answer the occupants’ questions”.
Sir Steve also condemned the abuse some people had directed towards Ms Butler on social media since Sunday.
“It is unwarranted and unacceptable and we are working to support her,” he said.
Mr Marsh told the PA news agency: “We are fed up with individuals being allowed to film my colleagues with impunity and put it out on every social media strand within five seconds, wherever they want, but we’re not allowed under legal grounds… to do the same, to put my colleagues’ body-worn camera out immediately.
“Now, that sounds a bit perverse, don’t you think, because we’ve got nothing to hide.
“I’m talking about transparency here.
“I, as the chair of 30,000 officers, am saying: put it out there.”
The federation represents thousands of rank and file officers in the London area.
John Apter, chairman of the Police Federation of England and Wales, said posting footage of such incidents on social media without context could stoke community tensions.
“It is clear in this case the officers have acted with the utmost professionalism,” he said.
“If people have a legitimate complaint about how they are dealt with then there are numerous ways people can raise their concerns – putting them all over social media without context is not the most constructive way.
“Our officers and the public deserve to be treated fairly but to continue to choose to conduct a trial by social media is damaging, unfair and can lead to social tension which in the current climate is highly irresponsible.”